Home Theater Systems - Electronics and Forum - HomeTheaterShack - View Single Post - Inconsistent Results
View Single Post
Old 11-17-06, 11:59 AM   #5 (Link)
abit late
Shackster
Alias: al
User: #2668
Since: Sep 2006
Posts: 11
  abit late is offline  
Re: Inconsistent Results


No, I haven't recently changed the cables in the rear.

Some more information about the problems I've been having...

The top attachment here shows the unfiltered curve. As you can see I have a big dip between 30 and 40 hz. The sub is currently in the front right hand corner of the room. The only other location for it is a little further left near the right hand speaker, or somewhere in between. I have moved the sub around and still get that dip in my listening position, which cannot parctically be changed.

I have attempted to equalize according to Ayreonaut's house curve that he recently posted. I used 12 filters to produce the second curve attachment. That was my first attempt which began with transposing the curve upwards to bring the bottom of the trough to a decent level before making some pretty major cuts elsewhere. The filters are as follows:

Filter ISOFreq BW Gain
1 49 10 -35
2 31.95 3 -17
3 83 6 -15
4 68 5 -9
5 35.8 2 8
6 57 4 -10
7 97 10 -20
8 29.35 4 -4
9 33.65 3 -2
10 44.5 5 -5
11 78 2 -3
12 25 20 -9

As you can see, there are rather a lot of quite severe cuts so I thought I'd have a go at doing it again with fewer filters. The result is the two curves in my first post - the REW plot alternates between the two. The filters were as follows:

Filter Freq BW Gain
1 32 8 -12
2 50 40 -8
3 63 15 -9
4 40 5 +4

Could the inconsistency be due to filter 2, i.e. having a cut over a large bandwidth (40)? Filter 2 (sometimes) has a very positive effect on the curve as a whole with the large bandwidth. But it seems that the four filter curve is sonically unstable in my room :holycow:

The 12 filter curve seems to give consistent results. However it requires the sub gain to be turned up from about 10 o'clock (unfiltered) to 3 o'clock, which is nearly maximum! I am concerned the 12 filter curve has too many large cuts and will have a negative effect on the available headroom and sound of the sub.

I would appreciate any thoughts that you may have, apart from the rude ones. My wife is certainly having a few thoughts about the amount this equalisation lark I expect that I need to try again and aim for fewer filters with a stable curve. One other question... is sweep the most accurate? The results seem to vary quite a bit for the different tone types, e.g. 1/6 oct versus sweep.

Thanks again

Al

Attachments
File Type: jpg unfiltered doors shut crossover 60.jpg (25.3 KB, 45 views)
File Type: jpg busy curve - final.jpg (25.5 KB, 46 views)

Forum Rules Reply With Quote