Hello Bryan and other interested parties. I would like to post some pertinent REW charts to begin analyzing and correcting my "man cave" 2 channel room which is dire need of some treatment. I am interested in bass trapping, diffusion and reflection treating in fairly bare room.
What REW charts are useful to start the discussion, SPL and Waterfall? In what range? My speakers are getting usable output into the low 30Hz range in room.
I am using REW with a RadioShack analog meter (from my reading may not be useful much higher than 3k) if that is helpful to know.
I also have a very rough layout of the room (using Paint).
I have been playing with REW and various seating locations as well, (basically distance from the back wall).
SPL and frequency response will help as will the diagram. Just save as a JPEG with at about 600-800 MP wide. You have to make five posts before being able to upload.
I just uploaded some jpg images although I think they aren't ready to attach yet. This will be my 5th post anyway. I think I actually had access to posting images by virtue of my donating status.
I'm a bit rusty on forum protocols so have to figure the system out for attaching them when they are ready.
I have a room layout and 3 waterfalls and 3 spl graphs from different listening position distances.
I find it interesting that prior to my getting a hold of REW I gravitated closer to the rear wall listening position due to the filling in or smoothing of the bass response that the graph's clearly show. However too close and the boom/echo is muddying up things.
The room is totally untreated except for a 8'x10' rug so it has quite a lot of slap echo.
I have pretty free reign on what I can get away with in this room. One consideration is that we will eventually be putting sofa/hide-a-bed against the rear wall for emergency guest overflow and probably for me on occasion.
I plan on properly testing as I incorporate room treatments to verify and optimize with guidance from folks.
I am also curious as to the effect of the large closet. There is over an inch gap between the hardwood floor and the bottom of the doors is this effecting things as well?
No I'm not using any EQ and would prefer not to add it at least at this point in my 2 channel setup. I think I'd like to take things as far as I can correcting the room issues passively first.
I am aware if them and may be checking them out for my home theater where I'm running dual subs.
Ideally, you'd be just under 6' from the rear wall to seated ear position. I know that seems close to the speakers but you have plenty of space behind them unless they're something special that requires that much distance. What are the speakers?
Waterfall is fine. Can you post a FR that has 5db increments on the left and runs from say 20-300Hz on the X axis?
Hi Bryan, the speakers are Reference 3A Episode they are rear ported which can be problematic getting too close to a wall. They typically seem to need some breathing room to blossom in sound stage depth. Manufacturer recommends pulling them out into the room. But I'm willing to try things.
The back of the speakers are about 38" from the wall. I might be able to squeeze them back about a foot or so, maybe slightly more. I neglected to show a corner glass shelf system that holds a printer and a my sat receiver in the back left (top right corner on drawing).There are two stacked Power Var transformers that take ac off from dedicated lines that take up some space on the floor next to the turntable. The right speaker (bottom right on drawing) has my VPI record cleaner behind it also. I'll have to doctor the room drawing to reflect these items.
Are you requesting a waterfall of any of the specific distance adjusted or all three?
Here are the revised fr graphs per your 5db increment from 20-300Hz. I have included additional distances I tested at with the speakers at 38" from the wall.
I did move the speakers back just to listen at 26" and definitely have the sound stage depth shrinking noticeably. I crude listening tells me I need them out at 33" minimum. I now have them at 34" and moved them to 29 1/2" off sidewalls. I haven't measured at this point.
Not to jump to any conclusions so early in this but wouldn't some treatment behind the speakers help to allow me to move the speakers back closer to the rear wall.
I'll do measurements with the speakers in this new location.
Bryan I have been moving things around and extrapolated your 6' to fit dimensions of the speaker locations. Tash at Ref 3A suggests 1.1-1.2 x speaker separation to lp distance. When I had the speakers in a monster room up north we settled on 8' apart with the listening position 9-10' away. That room was substantially larger and the ceiling was 10', the rear wall behind the speakers was 4-5' away and the wall behind the lp was about 12-14'.
Following are some fr graphs with the speakers 65" apart 27" from the wall and 37" from the side walls.
That's all I'll be able to work on for a few days.
The last two graphs were with the speakers locations changed dramatically from the earlier graphs. As noted the speakers are 65" apart rather than the original 80-86". They are now 27" from the wall behind them and 37" from the side walls. The lp was measure at 61" & 72" (your suggested) distance from the back wall behind lp.
Gotcha. My problem is that since we changed LP, and distance to front and side walls, we've changed 3 things so no telling what did what.
72" is definitely better for the first low null but some of the rest isn't as good as before. We just need to follow the scientific method and change only one thing at a time so we can see what is and isn't impacted.
For instance, keep the seat now at 72" and change the speaker positions slightly to see what changes.
Ok Professor "Shirley" following are plots with the speakers moved forward 6" thus 33" out from the wall and still at the 37 1/2" sidewall distance.
I did four graphs: 72"; 61 1/2"; 56" and 78" lp from back wall of the room.
The experience is rather enlightening> I'm starting to grasp the room effects much more. The focus and instrument placement have greatly been enhanced getting the lp out into the room. 27" was a bit stifling on the sound stage depth. Still room for improvement :T
Hey Bryan, I went ahead and varied the sidewall distance and measured since you didn't comment on the last post. It seems I'm not making much progress raising those nulls they basically just shift around in frequency.
This first graph is at the 37 1/2" sidewall distance as the previous post with more toe-in on the speakers.
The remainder progressively move closer to the sidewall.
I think I'll try moving moving the speakers back 3" to split the previous 27" and 33" distance from the wall and vary the toe-in some for comparison. Due to the high frequency dispersion characteristics of the speaker they can't be toed in as much as most speakers.
For giggles I decided to measure with the closet open both doors and with just the front doors open with speakers unchanged. I thought you should see these.
Well, the lower peaks got better but the null at 90 got deeper again. Might have to move the chair a little to see if you can avoid that now with the doors open.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Home Theater Forum and Systems
742.3K posts
170.9K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, home theaters, troubleshooting, projects, DIY’s, product reviews and more!