Electrostat Placement? - Home Theater Systems - Electronics and Forum - HomeTheaterShack
 
Home Theater Shack SVSound: The Sound Authority in speaker and subwoofers!  The new PB13-Ultra and PC-Ultra subwoofers are astonishingly awesome! Ultimate Home Entertainment: Providing home theater seating and accessories such as popcorn machines and signage... at very affordable prices! Parts Express: The #1 Internet source for all your DIY and electronics needs! Axiom Home Theaters: Award winning Internet direct speakers and subwoofers! Creative Sound Solutions: Loudspeaker kits and components for subwoofers, midwoofers, woofers and full range speakers! Mach 5 Audio: Affordable Drivers: Australian supplier of car and home audio subwoofer drivers of exceptional value! Fi Audio: Infinitely amazing balanced high end musicality designed drivers! SoundSplinter: A purveyor of exceptionally high quality subwoofers with a price tag that isn't heavier than their subs! Sony Style: Sony Audio and Video products! Ascend Acoustics: Award-Winning Audiophile Quality Loudspeakers Made Affordable Via Direct Sales! Funky Waves: A great source for custom subwoofers and speakers at incredibly low prices! HomeTheaterReview.com: Home theater equipment review publication that features av preamp, receiver, speaker, blu-ray player and more reviews. Musicians Friend: Find products for your REW and BFD setup... microphones, mic amps, Galaxy CM-140 SPL meter and more! GIK Acoustics: Home audio acoustics at its best... especially when you have help from the owners right here at the Shack!  Check out their very affordable acoustic panels! Discount Merchant:  If you need a replacement bulb for your video device... look no further... save big! Home Theater Shack Electronics Store: An Amazon store front specializing in audio and video electronics... and generally offering the lowest prices on the net!


    Home Register               Shack Shopping Glossary         FAQ            
Go Back   Home Theater Systems - Electronics and Forum - HomeTheaterShack > Manufactured Speakers and Subwoofers > Home Audio Speakers
Room EQ WizardBFD Guide
Forgot Password?
    Home Theater Links Donations         Image Gallery        

Home Audio Speakers

Electrostat Placement?

Discuss Electrostat Placement? in the Manufactured Speakers and Subwoofers forum; Electrostat Placement? I have just gotten a new pair of King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers ( http://www.kingsaudio.com.hk/products.html ). I was been messing ...


 Reply     Post New Thread
 
Thread Tools
Old 02-03-08, 12:29 AM   #1 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Electrostat Placement?


I have just gotten a new pair of King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers ( http://www.kingsaudio.com.hk/products.html ). I was been messing with them a bunch and wondered if anyone else had any good experience with Electrostats. They seem very directional, which is good for many things, but I wondering if there is a best setup to widen the sound field up a bit more. Any other advice on electrostats would be appreciated.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Alt Advertisement
Old 02-03-08, 12:36 AM   #2 (Link)
 
Shack Hillbilly
Platinum Supporter
Alias: Sonnie
Loc: Lower Alabama
Sonnie's Avatar
User: #1
Since: Apr 2006
Posts: 9,309
Sonnie is online now
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Never heard of them, but several of us here have Martin Logan electrostats... a proven company that has been in business for many years.

I'm not sure about other stats, but I would think they would be similar for setting up. With the ML's the sound stage is astronomically huge... setup didn't seem to effect the sound stage that much for me. For best imaging I toed my ML's in slightly. I used a flashlight and when pointing it at the speaker I could see a reflection at the inner 1/3 portion of the stat panel. Worked well for me.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-03-08, 01:32 AM   #3 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Yah, i've looked at a lot of martin logans. These have completely flat front, as opposed to the curved panel of many of the ML. Are your ML's hybrids or no?


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-03-08, 01:38 AM   #4 (Link)
 
Shack Hillbilly
Platinum Supporter
Alias: Sonnie
Loc: Lower Alabama
Sonnie's Avatar
User: #1
Since: Apr 2006
Posts: 9,309
Sonnie is online now
Re: Electrostat Placement?


My Ascent i's have a dynamic woofer crossed over at 280Hz to the electrostat panel.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-03-08, 04:36 PM   #5 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Yah these are full 58" by 18" electrostat panels, the mids/high are extremely impressive, and even though it is rated down to 48 hz, it definitely gets weeker on the lows... I am thinking about getting a powered subwoofer to go along with each one of the electrostats, thus making my own "hybrid" system.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-08, 05:09 PM   #6 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


just ordered two Infinity PS210 Subwoofers to go along with the electrostats... hopefully a crossover of 150 will be high enough to blend well with the electros


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-08, 09:43 AM   #7 (Link)
 
Senior Shackster
Alias: Jay
Loc: Western Wisconsin
jackfish's Avatar
User: #5100
Since: Dec 2006
Posts: 268
jackfish is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


I wouldn't be afraid of crossing over the PS210s at 50 Hz if the electrostats can actually deliver down to 48 Hz +/- 3 dB as I believe they have a rated frequency response of 48 Hz to 26 kHz +/- 3 dB. Try several different crossover points, you may find 50 Hz sounds best. The PS210s have a steep 24dB/Octave crossover slope and the two (ESLs and subs) might perform better overall crossed close to the effective low end range of the electrostats.

I also wouldn't be afraid to move the panels out into the room a bit, even perhaps following the Cardas Golden Angle theory: http://www.cardas.com/pdf/roomsetup.pdf Those electrostats radiate from the back as well and you may find more depth in the soundstage with them out from the wall a bit.


Last edited by jackfish; 02-06-08 at 10:12 AM.

Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-08, 09:55 AM   #8 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Well it does play quite low, however I will admit it doesn't have the same punch at the low frequencies that a regular subwoofer might. I guess I'll just have to play with some to see how i prefer it. I know many martin logan hybrids have there crossover as high as 460 hz.


2- 58" King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers
2- Infinity Audio PS210 Powered Subs to got with Electrostats
Jensen Center (soon to be replaced by: 1- Definitive Audio CLR2300 Center Channel
4- Technic SB-T100 (surrounds)
3- JL 10" Subs
Kenwood VR-6070 THX Receiver --- Denon AV600 ---- Technic SU-Z900
Acer XD1170 Projecter --- 120" Screen

Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-08, 10:28 AM   #9 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Very good to know, thanks for the advice. I'll have to play a bit with the crossover when the subs arrive to see how it works out. Right now my speakers are a couple feet from the wall, but I am unable to really move them much further out in my current setup. I'd love to play with them a bit more. I may soon be moving to a different home in which I may have more room to play with, I will definitely bookmark that link and keep that in mind when I am tweeking the system.


2- 58" King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers
2- Infinity Audio PS210 Powered Subs to got with Electrostats
Jensen Center (soon to be replaced by: 1- Definitive Audio CLR2300 Center Channel
4- Technic SB-T100 (surrounds)
3- JL 10" Subs
Kenwood VR-6070 THX Receiver --- Denon AV600 ---- Technic SU-Z900
Acer XD1170 Projecter --- 120" Screen

Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 02-06-08, 05:38 PM   #10 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Alright, well i've got the PS210's in and so far the really seem to be filling the gap that I needed. I can now easily listen to music in stereo mode with just the Prince's and PS210s. Also for full digital soundtracks the lows are really apparent in the front channels now. My LFE subwoofer is set to quitte a low crossover, so there was a lot of missing range. However, with a fully discrete system your front speakers should be able to take some pretty heavy lows anyways.

No, I have another question at the moment. My current LFE subwoofer its kind of makeshift. It can definitely punch, but its actually an old car sub box with 2 JL 10's in it. It does alright. However, in order to clean up some variation. I am tempted to blend the LFE in with my 2 SP210s. To do this I would run the Left Channel out + LFE out to my left sub, and Right Channel Out + LFE to the right sub. If I am correct this should blend the LFE in with the two, but still give the discrete punch from the fronts? Again, this is something I guess i need to test... and I may find it better to leave the extra JUST for the low LFE channel, but I figured I would ask for any opinions or if there is any other ways to work such a system.

I may also have a few more placement issues I will be looking into as soon as I get some pictures to post up.


2- 58" King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers
2- Infinity Audio PS210 Powered Subs to got with Electrostats
Jensen Center (soon to be replaced by: 1- Definitive Audio CLR2300 Center Channel
4- Technic SB-T100 (surrounds)
3- JL 10" Subs
Kenwood VR-6070 THX Receiver --- Denon AV600 ---- Technic SU-Z900
Acer XD1170 Projecter --- 120" Screen

Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-08-08, 08:02 PM   #11 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: AdamoDomingo
Loc: Virginia
User: #15653
Since: Jan 2008
Posts: 58
grapenuts is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


I'm curious as to what Xover you decided to go with? I wouldn't go as high as 150. That will make the sound a bit muddy if your subs aren't super musical. Vice Versa, I wouldn't drop it too far below 80 either. Then you get leaner bass as the Stats try to come up with some punch the Sub needs to be doing for you. If I were you with Full Stats and no hybrid woofer, I would set it right at THX first, then go up to 100 and as low as 70 and see where you fit. I would bet you will sound your best at 80-90.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-08-08, 11:25 PM   #12 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: BleedingStar
Loc: Las Vegas
User: #16356
Since: Feb 2008
Posts: 59
BleedingStar is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


I've found they were best set around 120 so far, Still might play around a bit.


2- 58" King Sound Prince Electrostat Loudspeakers
2- Infinity Audio PS210 Powered Subs to got with Electrostats
Jensen Center (soon to be replaced by: 1- Definitive Audio CLR2300 Center Channel
4- Technic SB-T100 (surrounds)
3- JL 10" Subs
Kenwood VR-6070 THX Receiver --- Denon AV600 ---- Technic SU-Z900
Acer XD1170 Projecter --- 120" Screen

Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-10-08, 01:05 AM   #13 (Link)
 
Senior Shackster
Alias: superchad
Loc: ohio
User: #17760
Since: Mar 2008
Posts: 261
superchad is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


I own Innersound Eros Electrostats which have flat panels like yours, I dont run mine anymore but still own them so here is what I learned.
As you know they need room from backwall, 3ft atleast but side wall is not very critical because of the narrow dispersion, placing items behind them to break up the backwave is very helpful.
When aiming the speakers I used a flashlight help next to my ear in my listening seat, when you see the beam reflected in center of panel on each side your in!
Also if they have spikes or feet you can lower the fronts or rears and play with the angle they fire towards you at, this can help define the soundstage and its height.........very useful.
You are going to need to use a Vacuum cleaner on that ESL from time to time......scratch that and please refer to owners manual, I will only say mine needed cleaned with a hoover every so often, the sound can get dull and cleaning them helps again look at your manual but I can share how I did things if you wish.
If I can help feel free to contact me, cheers


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-15-08, 10:28 AM   #14 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: Jonathan
Loc: Big Canoe, GA
JonFo's Avatar
User: #10219
Since: Jul 2007
Posts: 11
JonFo is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Dealing with the backwave of a dipole is critical to achieving the best sound from this style of speaker, and since ESL's radiate a LOT of high frequency to the rear (just as much as the front, unlike other ribbon or tweeter based line array dipoles), handling that is critical for best performance.

I run an all MartinLogan setup, design my own speakers and do fully active crossovers, and have posted a ton of information in related topics over on the MartinLogan owners forum.

Specifically, the big thread on positioning, treatments etc. for Electrostats; it's 230+ posts chock full of information, detailed measurements and some great discussion.

As for crossover points, I believe 120 is the lowest you should go on a panel, and personally use much higher settings on my large Monoliths.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-15-08, 10:54 AM   #15 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: AdamoDomingo
Loc: Virginia
User: #15653
Since: Jan 2008
Posts: 58
grapenuts is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Jon, you use much higher? then again you are actively bi-amping and using your own external xover. with the internals, I don't like the sound of the logans with an xover at 150 or even 120. I find it best right around THX give or take 10hz. If it's a hybrid, it can handle the lower duty I would think due to allowing the woofer to take on the lower duty. a straight stat panel is a different story though. I've read your design on your clxcenter build and it looks great! excellent job. I deal with the rear wave of my Ascent i's by absorbing a good portion of it but not killing it all together. high order frequencies are absorbed and it seems to do the trick nicely.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-16-08, 02:43 AM   #16 (Link)
 
Senior Shackster
Alias: superchad
Loc: ohio
User: #17760
Since: Mar 2008
Posts: 261
superchad is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


If I were you I would try to diffuse the backwave but leave the wall live behind them, if they are placed far enough from back wall and the backwave is broken up and scattered while leaving the surface live will give you more magic then absorbing the sound, I have not heard your set-up so I am just going on my own experience with my Electrostat Hybrid speakers....................cheers


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-16-08, 09:04 AM   #17 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: Jonathan
Loc: Big Canoe, GA
JonFo's Avatar
User: #10219
Since: Jul 2007
Posts: 11
JonFo is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Quote:
grapenuts wrote: View Post
Jon, you use much higher? then again you are actively bi-amping and using your own external xover. with the internals, I don't like the sound of the logans with an xover at 150 or even 120. I find it best right around THX give or take 10hz. If it's a hybrid, it can handle the lower duty I would think due to allowing the woofer to take on the lower duty. a straight stat panel is a different story though. I've read your design on your clxcenter build and it looks great! excellent job. I deal with the rear wave of my Ascent i's by absorbing a good portion of it but not killing it all together. high order frequencies are absorbed and it seems to do the trick nicely.

Grapenuts, I use the following crossover points for the Monoliths:

Panel to Monolith woofer (aftermarket mid-bass capable driver) is at 315Hz

Woofer to IB Sub is at 60Hz

If using the stock hybrid system crossover, you pretty much can only pick the transition to the sub x-over. So 80 to 100Hz is fine for most. Some could be crossed over lower (Summits) but still no lower than 40hz.

If going totally active like I did, you should never cross over from the panel below 200, even for the big Monoliths. SL3 or Sequel type panels should cross over closer to 400Hz based on my metrics and resulting designs.

Regarding rear wave damping, be careful to use broadband absorption. As only absorbing the extreme highs or even upper mids on up, will not yield positive results at all.
The best results come when absorbing from 200 or 300hz on up, the lower you can go, the better.
That requires treatments that are 3 or more inches thick. If you are using 2" foam, or some other thin treatment stuck to the wall, that is not the right type to have behind the speakers.

Also, beware of treatments that include a limp mass absorber (typically a plastic film) embedded in them, as the reflective properties of the plastic are also negative. The recommended class of device to put *behind* an electrostat is something like the RealTraps MiniTrap HF (special note to the HF part, as it’s the ‘HighFrequency’ absorber version that will not reflect the highs).
Place this offset 2” from the wall, and least 13” or more from the back of the panel for best results.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
Old 03-16-08, 09:20 AM   #18 (Link)
 
Shackster
Alias: Jonathan
Loc: Big Canoe, GA
JonFo's Avatar
User: #10219
Since: Jul 2007
Posts: 11
JonFo is offline
Re: Electrostat Placement?


Quote:
superchad wrote: View Post
If I were you I would try to diffuse the backwave but leave the wall live behind them, if they are placed far enough from back wall and the backwave is broken up and scattered while leaving the surface live will give you more magic then absorbing the sound, I have not heard your set-up so I am just going on my own experience with my Electrostat Hybrid speakers....................cheers

Superchad, I also used to believe in diffusion, and actually ran that way for years, but after measuring and trying more absorptive solutions, I've converted to the 'Damp it' side.

The true 'magic' is to have the rear wave bounced and delayed more than 15ms before arrival. If the reflections arrive at less than that, they really kill instrument definition, dialog intelligibility and the comb filtering is horrendous.

But very few rooms accommodate managing the rear wave to that extent. Even then, I'd still recommend that energy from the rear wave be at lower than -18dB relative to the front, which means some broadband absorption is still required.

But note that in the case of the rear channels, I still use 2D diffusion (combined with broadband absorption) to increase perceived ambient fields for the rears.

The other reason for broadband is that the biggest buzzkill with dipoles is the rear wave cancelations in the mid-bass region. But absorbing the mid-bass from the rear wave substantially helps in that frequency range. Now a double bass or electric bass guitar sound clearer and have greater power.


Forum Rules Reply With Quote
 Reply     Post New Thread

« Home Theater Shack > Manufactured Speakers and Subwoofers > Home Audio Speakers »

« Previous Thread   Next Thread »

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads, You may not post replies, You may not post attachments and You may not edit your posts.

Bookmarks
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Seat placement craigscheer Home Theater Design and Construction 3 01-18-08 12:50 PM
Projector placement bcrawfo2 Home Theater Projectors 13 09-25-07 08:58 AM
Screen placement help tango Projector Screens | DIY Screens 2 03-04-07 07:28 AM
Center Channel Placement help! robnsin1 Home Audio Speakers 5 01-24-07 05:05 PM
2 sub placement bobgenie Home Audio Subwoofers 30 10-17-06 07:46 PM




Mach 5 Audio



This site is better viewed with a screen resolution of 1024 X 768 or higher!
1280 x 1024 is preferred for the best viewing!!!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:12 AM.