I have just ordered a new FTW 21 and now am in need of some design help for a suitable box.
I am going for a large ported enclosure of around (but not limited to) 20cuft tuned to around 15hz, I want this thing to shake the house!
Mainly it will be used for HT but occasional music, my current sub is a 2 cuft sealed Boston Acoustic G5 12” (a truly underrated sub)
Attached is a couple of Winisd plots,
• 20cuft @ 15hz (Blue)
• 20cuft @ 12hz (Red)
• 10cuft Sealed (Yellow)
The 15hz tune seems to give the best response, however Chrapladm very kindly advised me that with a 12hz tune I will not need a HP filter.
I am thinking of contacting Graham (gperkins1978) and using his design service however I would like to publish all of this design online for others to use.
The reason being, I believe there are people out there who may overlook certain drivers purely because there aren’t many plans available.
And really, companies like IST really only exist in the DIY world…
Any thoughts?
Also, If there are any Aussies out there looking for the IST drivers, they are being imported by Sam at Affordable Drivers (Becoming Infrasonic Au) – Big thanks to him for looking after me
I think you can do a preorder and save some money when ordering the 21" subwoofer from Affordable drivers. I think they are about 715 dollars each but best to give them an email.
Depending on room gain I would think you would be happy with the 12hz tune for ULF or the 15hz tune. The 15hz tune will add more slam above the tune when compared to the 12hz tune but I am also not sure what you are used to. And being only 3 more HZ difference I think you should just compare 10hz tune vs 15hz tune.
LOL.....I am just using my pair of 21's in a sealed 6cuft cabinet. Mine will sound fine for me with music but I also have mains that will play down to 40hz just fine. I am also going to be adding four more 15's as soon as they come out. So I am adding as many speakers as I can but I like sealed cabinets myself.
You could always do a multi-tune cabinet like gperkins did with his Fi Q 18's. I think he had a subwoofer cabinet with 3 slot ports and with the 3 combination ports could tune it to 12hz-17hz and have the option of sealing it also.
If this will be the only sub, you desire high output, and you need crazy output because it's a huge space and you don't get room gain, I'd recommend 20hz tune with 17hz hpf. Model it and compare to 12hz (low enough to go without hpf) and you'll see why I want you to look at it. On the other hand, if the lone 21 is enough output with the 12hz tune, with room gain, then I recommend 12hz rather than 13-18hz; as stated, you won't need a hpf and output is only marginally lower.
The LLT will sound good, only the placement limitations have the potential to limit musicality since it is so large, something to consider.
I like the sound of a multi tune box, although a very complex design..
Attached is my WinISD plots, not sure what i have done wrong (different computer) becuase its indicating even with the 12hz tune that i will be exceeding Xmax with 1500W?
I put a 2nd order BW at 17Hz on the yellow, which tames that massive peak at around 25hz
The room it will be in is quite large & open, however its not going to stay there for ever.
Yellow = 20cuft 20Hz
Blue =20cuft 15Hz
Red =20cuft 12Hz
After finally simulating I stand corrected. You should not need a Hpass with 1000watts. With your electronics falling off at around 10hz you will not be getting a full signal to your subs.
Now with 1500 watts you are definitely hitting Xmax.
I would definitely go for the NU6000 with DSP. My best is to always go with the flagship amp of any Behringer line. Their specs are so inflated. I've used a NU6000 and it has the minimum amount of power needed for these 21's. Don't go with the NU3000 where they might be starved for power.
When gperkins did his multi tune ported sub I thought it was an awesome idea. You get all the different tunings and can still seal the subs if need be. The only bad thing I saw about it was the enclosures are big.
But if you have the room then I dont think there are many negatives. I also think multi-tune is good for getting the most out of your subwoofers if you only have a pair of them.
LG's have not been ordered yet. I was wanting to finish my 3 way build and then order the first clone amp. That will power the mid and bass part of my 3way. The 14K is $726usd +125usd. The 10Q's are 785usd + 125.
Prices are direct from Sanway. I seem to be emailing them constantly about their products. I wont be ordering my clone for another three weeks. So you might have yours before I do.
Big thanks to Graham for agreeing to help me out with this build, he has suggested a larger box of between 25-30cuft tuned to 13Hz to keep the port velocity down (around 33 m/s)
I have attached a few quick renderings of how this would look in the room, some what inconspicuous i think comes to mind.
I hid my subwoofer in a wall to get the WAF up. You could always do something similar or disguise it as a piece of furniture if you have such an issue. I am surprised how large that box is needed as I have 22cu.ft for two UXL-18. Looking forward to see how it turns out.
Wall mounting is unfortunately completely out of the question!
It could double up as a tv stand, not sure how well it would work with a rear projection tv though..
I want it to be a large box to get the most out of the woofer and the available power (best bang for buck!)
I personally would have it freestanding so you have the ability to move around as wrong placement would be a big mistake. Ideally you would want to put a sub in various positions and run some test sweeps in REW to see where best would. Then you could decide what to do in terms of design. This is not always possible hence why I think a freestanding box would be better. Two subs would help alot in terms of a better response but with one things are a bit trickier. You have quite a large room and alot of flexibilty in terms of positioning.
I do agree with Graham on varying the placement if you have those options. For me it was either in the wall or no subwoofer, since I had limited options I made it as large as I could. I was just offering some suggestions if that is something you had to worry about, sounds like you don't which is AWESOME!
Sam at affordable also said the drivers are stuck in customs right now.:hissyfit: I figured it would be 4eva to get my pair.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Home Theater Forum and Systems
742.3K posts
170.9K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, home theaters, troubleshooting, projects, DIY’s, product reviews and more!