Camilla Dickinson - DVD Review - Home Theater Forum and Systems -

Thread Tools
post #1 of 1 Old 08-22-15, 03:18 PM Thread Starter
HTS Moderator
Mike Edwards's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Tucson, AZ
Posts: 5,087
My System
Camilla Dickinson - DVD Review

Title: Camilla Dickinson


HTS Overall Score:73

“Camilla Dickinson” is a film adaptation of Madeline L’Engle’s young adult novel “Camilla,” which takes place in the 1940’s after World War I, and tells the story of fifteen-year-old Camilla (Adelaide Clemens) discovering her parents and best friend Luisa (Colby Minifie) are flawed human beings while also finding a kindred spirit in Luisa’s brother, Frank (Gregg Sulkin). Being the avid read-the-book-first sort of person I am, and given how much I’ve enjoyed what other books of L’Engle’s I’ve read over the years, it’s rather embarrassing to admit that I had no idea the book existed until I got the review copy of the movie. I’m sure you’ll forgive me.

Strictly movie speaking, I think this was supposed to be a coming-of-age film, but it turned into more a documentary of Adelaide Clemens facial expressions. How many times does she try to speak and fail? How pinched or teary-eyed can she get while her mother whines about needing more affection than her husband gives her? How awkwardly can she fidget while her father asks how often this greasy Frenchman comes to their apartment to see her (Non-spoiler: he’s not coming to see Camilla and everyone knows it). How long can she keep this nervous-happy curl of her lips every time she’s around Frank?

Now, it’s good that she can emote like that. I appreciated that I could see and infer some of her inner monologue. It helped sell her as a self-conscious, sheltered rich girl. It also provided a nice juxtaposition to the times when she speaks up and gives her opinion, or how her face lights up when she talks about being an astronomer. I thought she and Frank shared their scenes quite well, both of them shy around each other, trying to be themselves while struggling with trusting the other person enough to do it. It quite differs from scenes with Camilla and Luisa, where Luisa dominates the situation and constantly poke, prods, and picks at her friend when she wants to know something. Frank always waits. He doesn’t rush, which is why Camilla feels safe enough around him to open up.

While Camilla values the different relationships she has with the Rowen kids, and her interactions with each stretch her toward recognizing herself as an individual person in a confusing world, the dynamic between her and her parents, and the tension between them, stretches her the other way, toward stoic closure. Bluntly, I disliked her mother, Rose (Samantha Mathis), more than her father, Rafferty (Cary Elwes). Neither of them are balanced individuals. Rose grew up beautiful and most likely sees it as her only redeeming quality; she is used to being fawned over, both by men and her daughter, but as she grows older and her beauty fades, she has become increasingly co-dependent, clinging more and more to Camilla and Rafferty for affirmation that she’s loved, only to have each of them withdraw because she smothers them. The more she feels unloved, the more she interacts with aforementioned greasy Frenchman, Jacques (Salvator Xuereb).

Rafferty, though, maybe have been an ice king from the get-go. He’s portrayed as a mountain of a man (in aura, not in literal size) with a savvy business mind and great intelligence. He most likely married Rose because she was so lovely, and then found her to be rather silly. Over the years he seems to have withdrawn from her, not because she’s growing older, but because in her co-dependency, she accuses him of not caring enough, or not paying enough attention to her, et cetera. This may be true to a degree, but not nearly the degree that Rose claims. Raff is a little awkward toward his daughter, and rather domineering, but I believe both are a result of Camilla growing up and away from the family unit, and he inwardly needs the same sort of affirmation and stability Rose is so vocal about. His issue is that he makes decisions that alienate both wife and daughter and somehow doesn’t seem to see it’s a problem.

The greatest redeeming factor in “Camilla Dickinson” is the Stephanowski’s (Robert Picardo and Camryn Manheim). They’ve suffered a huge loss, and yet they don’t isolate themselves from each other. In fact, they border on nearly too perfect: it’s the suffering they’ve endured that evenly balances their seeming infatuation with each other. They’re the couple that Rose and Rafferty could learn from, the couple that helps Camilla see what marriage could be like, and the couple that embodies nearly every 1940’s stereotype for happiness. I watched them and both disbelieved what I saw (“no one is like that, ever”) and yet envied them. They stole the scene every time they entered frame.


Not Rated by the MPAA

“Camilla Dickinson” sports a fairly solid 1.85:1 encoded DVD with a color grading that leans towards the earthy and burnished look of autumn. Colors are solidly displayed, but never deeply bright or heavily saturated. the reds are toned down and the blues and greens are extremely deep and dark. Fine detail is solid, with plenty of nuances to pick up along the way, whether that be facial details or the longer nature shots. Black levels are very good, but lack some of the inky "punch" that a good hi def transfer can replicate. The grading, the colors, the contrast levels, they all try their best to imitate a period piece set in modern days, and in many ways it succeeds, considering it looks fairly dreamy and Victoria despite the modern day attire. "Camilla Dickinson" is a good transfer, and almost great in many scenes, but just a tad shy. Definitely an A- transfer.

The 5.1 Dolby digital track is quite impressive, and gives us just what one would expect for a straight up drama. The track is exceptionally front heavy with TONS of dialog throughout the movie, and that dialog is replicated beautifully. Balance between the center channel and the rest of the mix is excellent, with some very solid dynamic range for the genre. Surrounds get some mild ambient action, but nothing that will make you sit up and notice, which is the same for the LFE channel. There’s some heavy downbeats now and again, but this is mainly a low budget drama, so there really isn’t much besides some weight to the simple sounds, and a few moments of a vehicle making some low rumble.


• The Make of "Camilla Dickinson"
• Commentary With Filmmakers
• Deleted Scenes
• Trailer


As far as adaptations go, “Camilla Dickinson” is a shadow of “Camilla” the novel, though it gives Camilla a more active role in her development than the book does. It holds its own and delivers its own message: in a culture where women are viewed as homemakers or trophy wives, girls can be who they want to be, can form their own opinions, can stand up to their mothers and fathers, and can learn to forgive. Camilla is representative of the cliché misunderstood teen who just wants to escape a bad situation and is accused of associating with bad influences, when the bad influences are actually her parents. Yet she can still overcome her mother’s co-dependency and her father’s stone-walling when she allows herself to trust people she barely knows and gets to see another way to live.

Additional Information:

Starring: Adelaide Clemens, Samantha Mathis, Gregg Sulkin
Director: Cornelia Moore
Written By: Cornelia Moore (Screenplay), Madeleine L'Engle (Novel)
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 MPEG2
Audio: English: Dolby Digital 5.1
Studio: Cinedigm
Rated: NR
Runtime: 117 Minutes
DVD Release Date: August 25th, 2015

Buy Camilla Dickinson DVD on Amazon

Recommendation: Rental

More about Mike
Mike Edwards is online now  


camilla , dickinson , dvd , review

Quick Reply

Register Now



Confirm Password
Email Address
Confirm Email Address
Random Question
Random Question #2

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address



Activation requires you reply to an email we will send you after you register... if you do not reply to this email, you will not be able to view certain areas of the forum or certain images... nor will you be able download software.


See our banned email list here: Banned Email List

We DO NOT respond to spamcop, boxtrapper and spamblocker emails... please add @hometheatershack DOT com to your whitelist prior to registering or you will get nowhere on your registration.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML is not allowed!
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome