The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review - Home Theater Forum and Systems - HomeTheaterShack.com

Reply
 
Thread Tools
post #1 of 22 Old 07-05-11, 02:13 PM Thread Starter
Senior Shackster
 
Dave Upton's Avatar
IT Guy
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 701
The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review


Title: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Theatrical Editions) [Blu-ray]
Starring: Elijah Wood, Sean Astin, Viggo Mortensen, Sir Ian McKellen, Sean Bean, Orlando Bloom, John Rhys Davies, Dominic Monaghan, Billy Boyd, Liv Tyler, Andy Serkis
Directed by: Peter Jackson
Written by: J.R.R. Tolkein
Adapted Screenplay: Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, Stephen Sinclair
Studio: New Line(Warner Brothers)
Rated: PG-13
Runtime: 681 min (films only)
Release Date: June 28, 2011






HTS Overall Score:96

Movie:
Video:
Audio:
Extras:
Overall:


Synopsis:

The Lord of the Rings motion picture trilogy is based upon the novel "The Lord of the Rings" originally written by J.R.R Tolkein. Tolkein's book is considered to be one of the greatest novels ever written and to this day is regarded as the pre-eminent fantasy fiction work in existence. The story follows Frodo Baggins (Elijah Wood) a young hobbit who inherits a magical artifact of immense power from his uncle Bilbo. Forged by the dark lord Sauron in Mount Doom millennia before Frodo's birth, this ring has the power to enslave all life. In the final great battle of the last age the ring was cut from Sauron’s hand by Isildur, a prince of Gondor, using the broken blade of his dead father. When the ring was separated from Sauron his physical form was destroyed – leaving only his spirit behind - forever tied to his ring.

Over the centuries as the Ring was lost to the passage of time Sauron’s spirit has strengthened – now the maleficent spirits greatest source of strength remains the One Ring to which his soul is bound. Upon his reunion with the One Ring, Sauron will regain his former power and once again rule over Middle Earth.

When the wizard Gandalf (McKellen) discovers that Frodo's ring is the One Ring he must send Frodo on a desperate quest to the elven settlement of Rivendell to seek council and keep the ring from the clutches of Sauron's lieutenants, the nazgul. When Frodo and his hobbit companions Sam, Merry and Pippin arrive in Rivendell a council of the races of Middle Earth is convened and it is decided that the ring must be taken to Mount Doom - the only place where it can be destroyed. Frodo volunteers to be the ring bearer, and is joined by an alliance of humans, an elf and a dwarf on his quest to save Middle Earth.

Frodo and his companions will journey from the deepest dungeon to the highest peak in their attempt to reach Mordor without being sighted by the forces of Sauron. As the fellowship fights to survive the ring itself is the greatest enemy, always playing upon the desires of those nearby. Eventually it is left to Frodo and his best friend Sam along with an unlikely ally to take the ring into the heart of Mordor and destroy the dark lord once and for all.



The battle for Middle Earth first wowed viewers almost a decade ago as The Fellowship of the Ring was released in theaters. Over the next three years The Two Towers and Return of the King would be released to even greater acclaim. Many of us have waited for these to be available in a high definition format since the day we viewed Return of the King the first time in theaters – I count myself among this crowd. At the time of their release, each of these films broke new ground in terms of effects, cinematography, makeup, and overall film making. Together the three films have garnered an impressive 30 academy award nominations and 17 wins and still rank amongst the best movies of all time.



Rating: All three films are rated PG-13 for intense epic battle sequences and scary scenes. There is nothing inappropriate in the films – though young viewers may be frightened by the orcs, goblins and other creatures depicted.

Video:

As opposed to the VC-1 encode of the Theatrical Editions, the Extended Editions come to Blu-Ray with a high bitrate AVC encode spanning two discs for each film. The short answer is that we are finally free of the rampant DNR seen in the prior release. Since these are such important films, I'll discuss the picture quality of each release separately.





The Fellowship of the Ring

Warner listened to fans and reviewers and at long last we have a DNR free version of this film. Although the Fellowship of the Ring has always looked a little “soft” – even in theaters as some of you may recall, it never lacked in terms of fine detail. This time around, Warner has done a new transfer from the original 2k digital intermediate, and for the most part - left the picture alone. According to many news outlets, Peter Jackson and DP Andrew Lesnie personally oversaw the new release and even went so far as to redo the color timing for this release. This has many fans in a second albeit smaller uproar over an apparent shift from warm 6500k whites often approaching the Whiter-than-White colorspace, to the green/cyan end of the scale. While this is true in the release, it's quite shocking how easily you become accustomed to it and forget the change. Screenshots will show obvious differences but for the viewer it's quite hard to tell in motion that anything is amiss. The whole film appears to be slightly dark as a result of these changes as well, which is surprising given the prior releases. While I'm grateful we have our detail back - there is no explanation for why a film like this looks like it has lost about 20% of its brightness and whites never quite look like they do in the detergent commercials.

There is no doubt that the color timing changes will have enthusiasts debating until their fingers fall off and forums crash due to server load, thankfully, the other elements of the PQ are slightly less contentious. The horrible DNR present in the original Blu-Ray release is absent, and fine detail is back in all its glory. Gandalf's beard no longer looks like a crayon drawing, and facial detail like pores, stubble and skin texture is noticeable - even to the extent of makeup becoming visible on occasion. Detail is excellent and is truly at the resolvable limit of technical possibility given the DI was only at 2K resolution. Keep in mind the age of the film and even the most avid (and critical) videophile will be hard pressed to complain overmuch (color issues aside). Sharpness and clarity is excellent when called for but recall that stylistically much of this trilogy relies on softer focus during certain scenes as a story-telling mechanism. Although the "changes" have made the film as a whole darker, shadow detail is generally superb, with many fine examples in the night-time Shire chase and Moria. Blacks are inky and appropriately dense in Moria, but there is also some minor crush at certain points in the film - again mostly in Moria and the Shire chase. The overall brightness of the film is somewhat diminished, however this is going to be a subjective decision on the part of the viewer, provided your display is bright, you may not see much to complain about at all. The scenes where "detail" is lost in the darkness are mostly CGI to begin with, and on my bright display I didn't find any issues with the overall brightness, though the lost detail was a minor quibble. Very fine grain pattern remains visible throughout and truly enhances the epic film-like quality of this release.

I think we do deserve an official statement from Jackson and Lesnie regarding the color on this one, but like my previous review, I'm not expecting us to be saved by the next edition this time. Unless Warner agrees to exchange discs, this is it folks. Assuming that the color issue never gets resolved, my closing comment is from the perspective of choosing the lesser of many evils. While it's technically imperfect, this is unquestionably a massive improvement over its predecessor. While we would all prefer a release that doesn't have a deep-sea tint to it, this is still the version of the film to own. The value of high level detail, preserved grain structure and absence of digital manipulation far outweighs the tint and crush issues in my opinion.

While I am not a betting man, I suspect that when the entire Lord of the Rings Saga comes out (along with the two Hobbit films) in a few years, we'll quietly see a non-green tinted FOTR sneak back into the new collection, that is, when the extended saga finally comes out in 2017.



The Two Towers

Like its predecessor, The Two Towers is also greatly improved in this release. Though the DNR was less apparent in this film during the previous release as well, I can safely say that any DNR is no longer present. The quality of the picture maintains the trend seen in all previous releases, as each subsequent film looks better than the last. The Two Towers is full of rich detail, inky blacks and gorgeous shadow detail. Effects do look slightly dated at times, but given the age of the film they are mind-blowing and the folks at Weta Digital were far ahead of their time. No aberrations or artifacts are visible throughout the more than three hours of running time, and thanks to the two disc split, no quality is sacrificed. Film grain is maintained throughout and high level detail is very good. Facial detail from pores and stubble to wrinkles and scars is superb and organic. Unlike the TE, this release doesn't make it hard to distinguish hairs in some scenes and on the whole is a huge improvement. While there are some instances where a close-up shows a little bit of shimmer (particularly on hair) as a result of the chroma-keying process, this is an extremely limited occurrence and represents a technical limitation and not a picture quality issue.



The Return of the King

The Return of the King is the star of the show, with the best picture overall. Like prior releases, the newest film looks the best. Detail is superb and colors are rich and organic. From start to finish Return of the King borders on reference level and despite a few minor quibbles with respect to chroma keying (see the head shot of Frodo as Aragorn bows to him at the end) this is a great transfer and really benefits when DNR is absent. Don't be shocked by apparent softness in the image from time to time - this appears consistently and is a stylistic choice. Ultimately this film is a pleasure to watch from start to finish, even as hour four approaches. While I wish all three could look this good, Return of the King is a fine example of how the trilogy can look and is well worth your hard earned dollars.

Audio:

Reference.

Oh you want justification? Here goes:

From the first utterance of dialogue and detonation of a pilfered firework, the tone is set for the audio in this trilogy. Clarity of dialogue is incredible and never suffers intelligibility issues as a result of the mix. While Eowyn's voice is a little muffled during an extended conversation with Aragorn in Edoras, this is a result of the mic position and recording and not the mix.

Ambient sound and atmospheric effects are equally impressive as even the finest sonic detail is accurately reproduced. When the stolen firework explodes the surrounds come alive as tendrils of smoke and magic fizzle behind the viewer, and as the dragon plummets towards the party your sub will begin the start of an 11 hour workout. Without getting too verbose, from start to finish the trilogy of films has superb sound - deep prodigious bass, shocking dynamics, delicate and detailed atmospherics, and crystal clear dialogue. Howard Shore's score is as magnificent as ever and anchors the experience in rich and detailed instrumentals and powerful, moving vocals. No matter your preference, this folks is a fine example of reference.

Extras:


While there are no HD extras as we have come to expect, the sheer number and length of the extra content given here is mind blowing. I would love nothing more than to see these in HD, but I highly doubt the investment would pay off for the studio.

Please expand the spoiler tags to see the list of extras - they are extremely long and have been shortened in this manner for readability.

Bonus Features:

Spoiler


Disc 1 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring Extended Edition Part 1

The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - The Untold Story Trailer[HD]

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 2 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring Extended Edition Part 2

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 3 (DVD):


The Appendices Part 1 From Book to Vision

Peter Jackson Introduction

JRR Tolkien: Creator of Middle-earth – 22 minutes

From Book To Script – 20 minutes

Visualizing the Story – 39 minutes

Designing and Building Middle-earth – 96 minutes

Middle-earth Atlas – Interactive feature

New Zealand as Middle-earth - 10 minutes

Disc 4 (DVD):


The Appendices Part Two - From Vision to Reality

Elijah Wood Introduction

Filming The Fellowship of the Ring – 88 minutes

Visual Effects – 57 minutes

Post Production: Putting It All Together – 14 minutes

Digital Grading – 12 minutes

Sound and Music – 15 minutes

The Road Goes Ever On… - 7 minutes

Disc 5 (DVD):


Behind-the-Scenes Documentary Created by Filmmaker Costa Botes during filming of The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring – 85 minutes

Disc 6 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Extended Edition Part 1

The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - The Untold Story Trailer[HD]

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 7 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Extended Edition Part 2

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 8 (DVD):


The Appendices Part 3: The Journey Continues

Peter Jackson Introduction

JRR Tolkien: Origin of Middle-earth – 29 minutes

From Book to Script: Finding the Story – 21 minutes

Designing and Building Middle-earth – 89 minutes

Gollum – 45 minutes

Middle-earth Atlas - Interactive feature

New Zealand as Middle-earth – 14 minutes

Disc 9 (DVD):


The Appendices Part 4: The Battle for Middle-earth

Elijah Wood Introduction

Filming The Two Towers – 89 minutes

Visual Effects – 54 minutes

Editorial: Refining the Story – 22 minutes

Music and Sound – 48 minutes

The Battle for Helm's Deep is Over… - 9 minutes

Disc 10 (DVD):


Behind-the-Scenes Documentary Created by Filmmaker Costa Botes during filming of The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers – 106 minutes

Disc 11 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Extended Edition Part 1

The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - The Untold Story Trailer[HD]

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 12 (Blu-ray):


The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Extended Edition Part 2

Commentary with Peter Jackson & the writing team

Commentary with the Design Team

Commentary with the Production and Post Production team

Commentary with the Cast

BD-Live enabled

Disc 13 (DVD):


The Appendices Part 5: The War of the Ring

Peter Jackson Introduction

JRR Tolkien: The Legacy of Middle-earth – 30 minutes

From Book to Script – 30 minutes

Designing and Building Middle-earth – 118 minutes

Home of the Horse Lords – 30 minutes

Middle-earth Atlas

New Zealand as Middle-earth – 16 minutes

Disc 14 (DVD):


The Appendices Part 6: The Passing of an Age

Introduction

Filming The Return of the King – 73 minutes

Visual Effects – 43 minutes

Post-Production: Journey’s End – 89 minutes

The Passing of an Age – 25 minutes

Cameron Duncan: The Inspiration for Into the West – 32 minuet human interest story on a young terminally ill filmmaker

Disc 15 (DVD):


Behind-the-Scenes Documentary Created by Filmmaker Costa Botes during filming of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King – 113 minutes

Digital Copy: Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, Return of the King





Overall:

Despite its flaws, there can be no question that this release is the best that the trilogy has ever looked or sounded. Color timing issues in Fellowship aside, the picture quality as a whole is dramatically improved and all the ugly DNR is now gone. Fine detail, shadow delineation, and inky blacks are all present and accounted for. The unique style of these films, in combination with an encode/transfer that does them justice is a welcome change. Regardless of your level of obsession with this trilogy, or your manic obsession with picture quality, there can be no doubt that this is the best these films will ever look short of a complete re-scan and re-render of the effects. Fans have been waiting for an extremely long time for this release, desiring to own the full unabridged extended versions of these films on Blu-Ray. For those fans who held off on the theatrical release due to picture quality concerns, or simply to avoid double dipping, your time has come.

Irrespective of whether Warner does something about the first film's color issues, this is the time to buy the trilogy. As I stated in my original review, we could only hope that the DNR would be absent in the Extended Edition, and here I sit a year and a half later amazed that this is indeed the case. From start to finish, this is a great viewing experience that lasts over eleven hours. The reference quality audio never misses a beat and will give your sub and entire speaker system quite a workout playing back the dynamic and brilliant sound design present in these films. And at long last, the picture quality is finally worthy of our beloved Lord of the Rings - Warner might offer replacements on Fellowship, in fact I hope they do - but regardless, there is no higher fidelity way to own this trilogy at the time of my writing this. I strongly encourage you to go out and buy this release, a few gallons of high-caffeine beverage, 28 pounds of popcorn, and enjoy a sunup to sundown Lord of the Rings marathon. If you still have energy after all this, feel free to write an angry letter to Warner decrying the terrible green hue you just witnessed 8 hours ago. Most of you I suspect will be far too satisfied, bleary eyed and hopped up on caffeine to bother. I wish you many happy repeat viewings of this trilogy and the associated extra content, Highly Recommended.



Res non sententia.

Last edited by Dave Upton; 07-27-11 at 09:25 AM.
Dave Upton is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #2 of 22 Old 07-05-11, 06:29 PM
Elite Shackster
 
ironglen's Avatar
Glen
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: West Texas
Posts: 1,538
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review



My time has come!

(can I afford it?)

Thanks for the review!
ironglen is offline  
post #3 of 22 Old 07-06-11, 02:15 AM
Shackster
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: huntington beach
Posts: 7
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

can't wait......
nick714hb is offline  
post #4 of 22 Old 07-06-11, 07:38 AM
Senior Shackster
 
Vader's Avatar
Derek
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Colorado
Posts: 402
My System
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Nice review, Dave!

I have been back and forth on the fence on this one, following all of the controversy concerning the tint on FotR. These films have special meaning for me, and have been my proverbial "holy grail" for release on Blu-ray (yes, even above Star Wars). For the time being, I have decided to wait until a definitive statement is made, not necessarily the "what" of the matter, but the "why"... exactly what did Jackson intend the tint to evoke in the viewer? I know that he did go on record saying that the re-color timing was intentional, but it seems to be the general consensus that the green tint is in addition to that. The one thing that has always been a strength of these films (for me, anyway) is the visual continuity between each film, and for this tint thing to disrupt that is almost enough for me to simply stick with the EE DVDs and wait for the "Hobbit + LotR" set. That it should be done to only the first film brings back memories from 2004 of "it was an artistic decision to reverse the surround channels for Star Wars ANH only" (in the 2004 SE DVD release). Eventually, I suspect I will cave in, if anything for the audio (DTS-HD MA, baby!...)

Peace... Vader

"Ya see, we plan ahead. That way we don't do anything right now. Earl explained it to me." - Valentine McKee

One sub to rumble them all. One sub to shake them. One sub to humble them all. And in the darkness break them....

The Overlook Theater - Not liable for injuries sustained while laughing.

Last edited by Vader; 07-07-11 at 11:55 AM.
Vader is offline  
post #5 of 22 Old 07-06-11, 09:02 AM
Senior Shackster
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Minnesota
Posts: 350
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Big deal! Adjust your color balance for FOTR.
Theresa is offline  
post #6 of 22 Old 07-06-11, 10:33 AM
Senior Shackster
 
Vader's Avatar
Derek
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Colorado
Posts: 402
My System
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Quote:
Theresa wrote: View Post
Big deal! Adjust your color balance for FOTR.
My point is that something is wrong if you have to recalibrate your display for a specific title (otherwise the calibration standards for 6500K would be meaningless)...

Peace... Vader

"Ya see, we plan ahead. That way we don't do anything right now. Earl explained it to me." - Valentine McKee

One sub to rumble them all. One sub to shake them. One sub to humble them all. And in the darkness break them....

The Overlook Theater - Not liable for injuries sustained while laughing.
Vader is offline  
post #7 of 22 Old 07-06-11, 11:10 AM
Senior Shackster
 
smurphy522's Avatar
Scott
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Cypress, TX
Posts: 255
My System
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Watched the 1st two so far. Yes color calibration was a question I had going on in my head as they just seemed "off". Other than that mild distraction you only really get "out of the gate" I say this set is a winner!

There can be only one........set.

I would have written less but I didn't have the time.
smurphy522 is offline  
post #8 of 22 Old 07-08-11, 04:43 PM
Senior Shackster
 
Cyberfloatie's Avatar
Doug
 
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Kelowna, BC, Canada
Posts: 108
Thumbs up Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Great review! I've have been waiting for the EE for a long time after having given my father my EE DVD set a couple years ago. Like others I am bothered by the FotR green tint and would love to hear what Mr. Jackson has to say about it. Alas, my children (4 & 3) are too young to watch it and so I shall refrain from purchasing it for myself until the time that I can enjoy it with them.
Cyberfloatie is offline  
post #9 of 22 Old 07-08-11, 05:01 PM
Elite Shackster
 
Dale Rasco's Avatar
Dale Rasco
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Houston, Tx
Posts: 4,127
My System
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Quote:
Vader wrote: View Post
My point is that something is wrong if you have to recalibrate your display for a specific title (otherwise the calibration standards for 6500K would be meaningless)...
I agree, it is wrong to have to recalibrate your display for a single title. By the way, are you Jeff Vader?

Regards,
Dale Rasco




“Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work." -Thomas A. Edison


Dale Rasco and Temple of Boom REDUX

Shiva 12" Build
Dale Rasco is offline  
post #10 of 22 Old 07-08-11, 07:16 PM
Senior Shackster
 
Vader's Avatar
Derek
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Colorado
Posts: 402
My System
Re: The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Editions) - Blu-ray Review

Quote:
Dale Rasco wrote: View Post
I agree, it is wrong to have to recalibrate your display for a single title. By the way, are you Jeff Vader?
Hi Dale,

Nope... no Jeff here...

I just looked at "The Temple of Boom", and it's that kind of thing that makes me embarrassed to show my setup... Very nice!!!!

Peace... Vader

"Ya see, we plan ahead. That way we don't do anything right now. Earl explained it to me." - Valentine McKee

One sub to rumble them all. One sub to shake them. One sub to humble them all. And in the darkness break them....

The Overlook Theater - Not liable for injuries sustained while laughing.
Vader is offline  
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
bluray , editions , extended , lord , motion , picture , read , review , rings , trilogy

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now




PLEASE COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED FIELDS BELOW... THANKS!

REQUIRED FIELDS ON THIS PAGE
YOU MUST COMPLETE ALL OF THESE

Username
Password
Confirm Password
Email Address
Confirm Email Address
Random Question
Random Question #2




User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
PLEASE READ BELOW PRIOR TO ENTERING AN EMAIL ADDRESS!

ATTENTION!

YOU MUST ACTIVATE YOUR ACCOUNT!

Activation requires you reply to an email we will send you after you register... if you do not reply to this email, you will not be able to view certain areas of the forum or certain images... nor will you be able download software.

AN INVALID EMAIL ADDRESS WILL CAUSE YOUR ACCOUNT TO BE DELETED!

See our banned email list here: Banned Email List

We DO NOT respond to spamcop, boxtrapper and spamblocker emails... please add @hometheatershack DOT com to your whitelist prior to registering or you will get nowhere on your registration.


Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.


Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page



Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML is not allowed!
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

 


For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome