Ive never used the THD function, so I'll be watching this one with very keen interest. Also, you know the inevitable question from me . You fancy some sealed comparisons :R
The ported in theory should actually show less distortion around the port tune, and especially so at higher spl levels.
One thing to be wary of is using frequencies where the harmonics coincide with your local mains frequency and its harmonics, as any hum pickup (electrical or acoustic) would skew the results (though those would show up when the tone wasn't playing). That aside, see how the distortion levels change if you reduce the output level by 10 and by 20dB. It would also be worth measuring each of the sub's playing alone.
9 % difference between -10 and -20 is a fair swing. It shows how much high spls demand. I do wonder though how much this would change with a different amp.
Its probably be down to the amp, so its entirely possible, but having never having done this myself before I couldnt honestly say for sure. The sealed sub will tax the amp more driving distortion up a little more as your results show. You would have to try another amp to see the effects though. As long as your drivers are within xmax, they should contribute little to any distortion produced.
The wierd thing is that it doesn't sound the slightest bit distorted even at high levels so why is the RTA show up crazy distortion levels. How do I found out what the cause is?
How would you know what the specific distortion sounds like without hearing the same setup with less distortion for comparison. If it was that easy to simply hear, we wouldnt need REW. This is the whole point of this kind of program, it shows you these things without the need for masses of experimentation and comparison.
Ive seen it said, that with the lowest frequencies, its almost impossible to detect distortion till it reaches at least 10%.
Maybe, maybe not :huh:, I cant really speak for you. To detect something like this though, you need a comparison benchmark unless its ridiculous and entirely obvious. You may well be hearing it, you may just not know it. You could be doing something wrong when testing for all I know and getting duff result. We need an RTA expert to jump in here I think to be honest.
The largest distortion component is the second harmonic, which does not sound "distorted" (think tube amp ). High even harmonic distortion orders are typical of overdriven single-ended amplifiers, look carefully at the levels through the chain to the sub. The other thing to be careful of is what you are using to measure with. SPL Meter? Mic? If mic, be careful of premap gains and levels. If SPL Meter, make sure the range is appropriate.
I am using the Radioshack analogue meter. I had it set to 70db for setting up my levels. So if I am running at a level off 94db then I need to change the radioshack to 90db range setting. Is that correct.
I am using the Radioshack analogue meter. I had it set to 70db for setting up my levels. So if I am running at a level off 94db then I need to change the radioshack to 90db range setting. Is that correct.
Yes, the meter is easily overloaded so needs to be in the right range. You should also run through the SPL level calibration after you change the meter range so that REW understands the overall gain change that has happened (otherwise your plots will be drawn lower than they should be). You can just use your usual test signal (e.g. a receiver test tone at 75dB), enter in REW the reading that would give on your meter when your meter is on the 70dB range, but leave the meter set to the 90dB (if that makes sense) - you are basically telling REW that even though the electrical signal it is seeing is lower, it still corresponds to 75dB acoustic level.
Maybe not relevant to such "huge" distortions, but I usually tick "Lock frequency to FFT" in "Generator" - it helps to measure tweeter (or amp) distortions, where we deal with tenth of percent's.
OP: did setting the range differently change distortion readings? Did you try another amp?
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Home Theater Forum and Systems
742.3K posts
170.9K members
Since 2006
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, home theaters, troubleshooting, projects, DIY’s, product reviews and more!