Which subwoofers would you like to see being tested?

**russ.will** · **01-31-07, 04:58 PM**

Quote:

cjwhitehouse wrote:

Yes, we did screw up the settings on the MX350. One can only be in so many places at the same time on a testing day. Besides, he who never made a mistake never did anything.

Too true and I've done enough things to make a lot of mistakes!!!

Nice to see you here and I look forward to the next test.

Russell

**Ilkka** · **02-01-07, 06:22 PM**

Quote:

Chrisbee wrote:

Russell

The M&K350 has been tested (by Ilkka under another nom de plum) on AV Talk.

Obviously I didn't want to mention this on the M&K thread on AVF.

As CJ said, I have nothing to do with AV Talk's subwoofer tests. Although I can say that they were one of the reasons why I started doing my own.

**Chrisbee** · **02-03-07, 06:28 AM**

Quote:

Ilkka wrote:

As CJ said, I have nothing to do with AV Talk's subwoofer tests. Although I can say that they were one of the reasons why I started doing my own.

Then it seems I owe you an apology Ilkka.

I saw a sub being tested out of doors and immediately thought "Ilkka!".

I'd better apologise to cjwhitehouse too, while I'm at it. Everybody else can stand in the queue.

**tdamocles** · **02-11-07, 10:37 AM**

How about a mirage s12?

**Blaser** · **03-04-07, 03:51 PM**

I would like to see this one thested!!

http://www.wharfedale.co.uk/model.php?model_id=114

B Rgds
Blaser

**jpk** · **03-06-07, 11:54 AM**

How about testing a sub or two from ACI, the subs are in a sealed enclosure.

http://www.audioc.com/speakers1/titanxl/titanxl.htm

http://www.audioc.com/speakers1/maestroxl/maestroxl.htm

**WillyD** · **03-28-07, 09:40 PM**

When are you gonna test one of the TC-2000/BKA creations?

**SteveCallas** · **03-29-07, 01:53 PM**

I'd imagine he will have some TC 2000 results fairly soon

**Vader** · **03-29-07, 03:12 PM**

I'm sure it has been mentioned, but I would like to see results for Bose, or Orb (a Bose clone from what I understand)...

**Ilkka** · **03-29-07, 03:53 PM**

Quote:

WillyD wrote:

When are you gonna test one of the TC-2000/BKA creations?

There will most probably be at least one large and low tuned subwoofer (probably TC-2000 15") in my next measurement session in early May. Also other "heavy duty" DIY subs will be there. Just wait.

**Ilkka** · **03-29-07, 04:00 PM**

I will soon open a new thread about the upcoming measurement session. Though not every requested sub will be there, many interesting ones will.

And of course we still have around month to go so anything can still happen...

**Ilkka** · **03-29-07, 04:03 PM**

Quote:

SteveCallas wrote:

I'd imagine he will have some TC 2000 results fairly soon

I should have a lot more info regarding this tomorrow...

**SteveCallas** · **03-30-07, 01:20 AM**

Excellent.

**RuneW** · **03-30-07, 08:00 AM**

Quote:

Ilkka wrote:

I should have a lot more info regarding this tomorrow...

Well? Today is yesterday's tomorrow...

Sorry, I'm just (very) curious, because I've made one or two TC-2000 thingies myself...

**Ilkka** · **03-30-07, 04:54 PM**

Quote:

RuneW wrote:

Well? Today is yesterday's tomorrow...

Sorry, I'm just (very) curious, because I've made one or two TC-2000 thingies myself...

Almost done, not quite yet though. Hopefully tomorrow is the day.

**Ilkka** · **03-31-07, 05:24 PM**

Okay, a little sneak peak to something that has been cooking for some time now.

Not completely OT since this sub will be participating in my next measurement session.

Pic of the other end. Guess what the other end has??

In-room frequency response with mains. Some EQ in the upper bass range, but no L/T or similar. 11-13 Hz dip is room induced.

Just a quick SPL/THD test at 15 Hz (mic at LP). Nowhere near max output as one can see from the THD figure.

Lots of more to come in the near future.

**bossobass** · **03-31-07, 08:49 PM**

AWWWWWWW-SUMMMMM!

Your room and that 16Hz mode looks almost perfect with the sub's roll off. (You cheated picking 15Hz for the THD graph)

When did you get the Sound Tech software?

Did you experiment with placement, or just stick it where you always have the sub?

What kind of wood? Looks like maple or alder. Looks excellent!

Is it passive?

What power plant?

How many cubes?

What material for the tube? Is it painted or other?

Stuffing?

Everyone knows that engineer geeks can't build stuff, so who helped you with the baffles?

Looking forward to all the info.

Bosso

**SteveCallas** · **04-01-07, 11:17 AM**

Interesting that the room doesn't create a lot of distortion at 15hz - I thought non close mic in room THD measurements down low were useless because the room itself will resonate and such. Guess not. Looking forward to the full gamut

**Ilkka** · **04-01-07, 02:17 PM**

Quote:

bossobass wrote:

AWWWWWWW-SUMMMMM!

Your room and that 16Hz mode looks almost perfect with the sub's roll off. (You cheated picking 15Hz for the THD graph)

When did you get the Sound Tech software?

Did you experiment with placement, or just stick it where you always have the sub?

What kind of wood? Looks like maple or alder. Looks excellent!

Is it passive?

What power plant?

How many cubes?

What material for the tube? Is it painted or other?

Stuffing?

Everyone knows that engineer geeks can't build stuff, so who helped you with the baffles?

Looking forward to all the info.

Bosso

Whooah, a lot of questions considering how much info you have given from your own sub(s).

I will promise to open a new thread, but here are some basics before that.

2 TC-2000 15", opposed firing
5 cu ft / 140 L net
508mm ID, 12mm / 1/2" thick sonotube, lined with 1 1/2" eggcrate foam, covered in black felt
30mm end caps made out of heat-treated birch with a CNC machine
two 18mm inner end caps per end made out of HDF
total weight around 55kg / 120lbs
2.4 kW pro amp (drivers in series, amp bridged)
Behringer DCX2496

**Ilkka** · **04-01-07, 02:18 PM**

Quote:

SteveCallas wrote:

Interesting that the room doesn't create a lot of distortion at 15hz - I thought non close mic in room THD measurements down low were useless because the room itself will resonate and such. Guess not. Looking forward to the full gamut

It is a problem IF the room resonates. Mine doesn't have problems at those levels.

**bossobass** · **04-01-07, 02:47 PM**

Quote:

Ilkka wrote:

Whooah, a lot of questions considering how much info you have given from your own sub(s).

I will promise to open a new thread, but here are some basics before that.

2 TC-2000 15", opposite firing
5 cu ft / 140 L net
12mm / 1/2" thick sonotube, lined with 1 1/2" eggcrate foam, covered in black felt
30mm end caps made out of heat-treated birch with a CNC machine
two 18mm inner end caps per end made out of HDF
total weight around 55kg / 120lbs
2.4 kW pro amp (drivers in series, amp bridged)
Behringer DCX2496

Heh-heh, point taken. It's good to see that you'll have a decent representation of a dual opposing driver sealed sub for objective data.

I was wondering if you would take a measurement of the sub with the graph expanded to 2Hz, with the DEQ in the chain and without it, to see the effect, if any on the sub's extension, in-room?

When you take the sub outdoors, will you measure at different tunes (by EQ), or just as a passive sub? You should be close enough to a natural .71 Q to be able to apply a shelf boost at 2 additional points to note the power compression price for extension's sake, no?

Thanks for the sneak peek! Looking forward to the thread and further ahead to the GP session results.

5 cubes is a pretty big sub for a sealed unit. How does it compare in overall size to your SVSub?

Bosso

**Ilkka** · **04-01-07, 03:34 PM**

Quote:

bossobass wrote:

I was wondering if you would take a measurement of the sub with the graph expanded to 2Hz, with the DEQ in the chain and without it, to see the effect, if any on the sub's extension, in-room?

It's not the DEQ, it's the DCX. It's pretty easy and much more reliable to measure the DCX itself. Here's the frequency response: it's for example 3 dB down at 5 Hz. IMO that's pretty good compared to say Velodyne SMS-1 which is ~29 dB down at 5 Hz, and to Onix R-DES which is ~8 dB down at 5 Hz.

Quote:

When you take the sub outdoors, will you measure at different tunes (by EQ), or just as a passive sub? You should be close enough to a natural .71 Q to be able to apply a shelf boost at 2 additional points to note the power compression price for extension's sake, no?

Not decided yet, but I have though about measuring at least two different EQ settings: one close to natural, and another with ~12 dB L/T.

Quote:

5 cubes is a pretty big sub for a sealed unit. How does it compare in overall size to your SVSub?

5 cubes may be big to someone, but when you're used to the SVS Plus/2, it looks really small. OD for the tube is 532mm, distance from end cap to end cap is 810mm.

My main speakers are 1 meter tall.

Advertisement