Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review - Home Theater Forum and Systems - HomeTheaterShack.com

 
Thread Tools
post #1 of 4 Old 06-23-09, 08:43 AM Thread Starter
Senior Shackster
 
chrisy's Avatar
chrisy
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Hudson Valley NY
Posts: 166
Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review

Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review

I know what you are thinking: "Jerry - you spent $2,000 on a Blu-ray player. Are you out of your mind?" Yes, I am out of my mind, for reasons other than my willingness to spend on my home theater as if there is no recession, yet the investment in a significant Blu-ray player for my main home theater rig is looking better and better each day. The common misconception about Blu-ray is that, because it is clearly superior as a format compared to DVD-Video, you can simply buy a cheapie Blu-ray player and get topnotch performance. While a lower-priced Sony BDP-S360 is a very capable unit, it doesn't come with the "Elevated Standards" (the ES in Sony ES) that come with the higher-end players. Let me tell you - they make a difference if you are a discerning enthusiast of both audio and video.

The Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray player is priced with a retail of $1,999 and is a physically significant unit at three rack spaces tall. The industrial design harks back to older, high-end Sony disc players, which were always solid and reliable. Older, first-generation higher-end Blu-ray players and even some HD DVD players (sorry to bring that up) were slick as spit in terms of the faceplate and overall aesthetic, but many times developed "disc player erectile issues" (otherwise known as DPEI), causing limp drawers and poor-fitting parts. Sony's ES units are thankfully built like a tank and never suffer from DPEI. Under the hood, Sony uses what they call "Rigid Beam" technology to reduce jitter and other vibration-oriented distortions that degrade performance in any disc players, Blu-ray included. Another one of the calling cards for Sony ES products is that they go to great lengths to isolate the power supplies from many of the functioning boards in the unit. Considering how computer-like a Blu-ray player is, this important analog improvement is often overlooked in cheaper players, as it costs serious money to use the better parts. For all of us who don't shop for our gear at Wal-Mart, I would like to say thank you for the attention to detail, as I have owned easily a half a dozen Blu-ray players, ranging in price from $1,200 to the cheapie units, and they all pretty much stink in their own special way. I was more than ready for something higher-end and Sony was up to the challenge.

For those of you who haven't heard DTS Master Audio and/or Dolby True HD or are waiting to make the upgrade, you are really missing out. The HD audio bandwidth is nothing short of incredible, as it provides a surround sound experience that is genuinely jaw-dropping. Yes, you need the right AV preamp or HDMI receiver, which for most of us requires a component upgrade, but it is worth the money and effort for the incredible 7.1 HD surround sound. I recently upgraded from a Classe SSP 600 to the new Classe SSP 800 AV preamp to allow for more HDMI switching, better system control and the hot new surround sound formats. Traditional Dolby ProLogic and DTS sound uninspired in comparison to their HD brethren. The Sony BDP-S5000ES is the perfect source component to play back Blu-ray discs via HDMI or the very good 7.1 analog outputs offered as output options on the player.

The Sony BDP-S5000ES comes with IR control and, more importantly for my system, an RS-232 port so that I can control the unit via a Crestron touch panel. Custom installers need this level of connectivity to make their players work perfectly every time in larger, custom-installed systems. The BDP-S5000ES is internally loaded with a 14-bit processor, which allows the full 1080p/24 frames per second HD experience, as well as scaling of legacy content from DVD-Video at various resolutions, specifically 480i up to 1080p. The Sony BDP-S5000ES is a Blu-ray Profile 2.0 player, meaning that it can keep up with the breakneck pace at which Hollywood studios are loading discs up with player-crashing features. The Sony BDP-S5000ES will not crash and it will play every disc you can currently buy, which is something I cannot say about my outgoing Sony BDP-S1 Blu-ray player. That sucker needed constant firmware updates to play blockbusters like The Dark Knight. The Sony BDP-S5000ES is capable of all of the features of BD-Live, if you care. I know Sony and the studios love all of the games, tricks and sizzle-laden features from BD-Live. Personally, I just want the movie to play, and fast. Speaking of fast, thankfully the load time for the BDP-S5000ES is much improved over my last player.

Performance
I started out my testing of the Sony BDP-S5000ES with stereo compact discs under the theory that, at $1,999, for many consumers, this disc player should be able to replace their CD transport and/or player in their systems. Starting out with "Come On (Let the Good Times Roll)" from Electric Ladyland (MCA, Compact Disc), you could hear very good stereo separation. The bass sounded tight and the overall tone of the track was accurate, although a little dry compared to my reference Classe CDP-502 player. The onscreen menu is very nicely designed, with a sort of cityscape background, nifty sans-serif fonts and a cool track count and time-remaining element. Many people listen to their music with their TVs on these days, so the improved interface is appreciated. The lack of fast-forward and reverse buttons on the front panel of the machine is a glaring mistake for anyone looking to just spin a disc without an onscreen interface, as old-school audiophiles don't like having to turn on a monitor to play a disc.

In an odd format torture test, I reached for one of my most beloved demo discs, the self-titled Audioslave album on DualDisc (Epic - DualDisc). This 20-bit stereo track is a killer, so I cued it right up on the Sony BDP-S5000ES. The track "Show Me How to Live" has righteous bass and the S5000ES did a faithful job reproducing it. The cymbal crashes and highs were not as liquid or warm as you hear on audiophile CD/DVD players costing many times more than this Sony Blu-ray player, so for those looking for the ultimate in audiophile reproduction, don't be so quick to dump your tricked-out, esoteric players. For 98 percent of everyone else, the Sony BDP-S5000ES is perfectly suitable for legacy formats like CD and DualDisc.

Disappointingly, the Sony BDP-S5000ES will not play any SACD discs that I own, including Miles Davis' Kind of Blue, Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon or Peter Gabriel's So. Considering there are still many audiophile record labels out there still making music in high-definition via SACD, it's a disappointment to have a high-end disc player that won't play the format. I was pleasantly surprised that I could get beaming, hard-panning 5.1 surround sound from DVD-Audio discs like Queen's The Game (DTS Entertainment) in DTS surround, not MLP. The massively overdubbed vocal harmonies on the chorus of the attitude-riff-driven "Dragon Attack" provide a very suitable demo. The onscreen lyrics remind you how silly this song is, so I would recommend you shut your HDTV off for this one, but the surround demo is pretty hot. Sting's best album, ...Nothing Like the Sun on DVD-Audio (DTS Entertainment), also played flawlessly, but lacked any menus (a DTS issue, not a player issue) and automatically reverted to the cityscape backdrop, which was just perfect. The cymbals sounded a bit tinty on "Englishman in New York" compared to how they were on Meridian's $24,000 reference 800 disc player, as you might expect. However, the surround sound effects were fantastic. The alto sax at the very end of the track sounded round and very musical. Other DVD-Audio discs, including Buena Vista Social Club and Yes' Fragile, defaulted to the DVD-Video section of the disc and played in Dolby Digital, not MLP, which is an audio downgrade compared to the lossless MLP, but at least they played in 5.1 on the player.

Moving on to DVD-Video, I spun up an all-time classic comedy, Cheech and Chong's Up in Smoke (Paramount Home Entertainment - DVD-Video). In Chapter 2, "Is That a Joint," you might expect the video to be pretty fuzzy for reasons having to do with the information on the actual disc, but you likely would be shocked to see how resolute the images look as the comedy duo head south on PCH from 1970s Malibu. You can see the actual texture of the plush carpet installed on the doors of Cheech's "customized" car. You can see the gleam from his chrome chain-link steering wheel as the sun beams upon it. You can see embers on the zeppelin-sized joint that they smoke while driving in the car. Overall, you can tell the age of the film stock, but the film looks exceptionally good upconverted from 480i to 1080p. There is no noticeable pixelization. The colors are as vibrant as you would expect from a movie of this age, as the internal video processing does a commendable job of making 480p look like more like native 1080p high-definition. Considering how many movies are not yet offered in Blu-ray, upscaling should not be overlooked when considering which Blu-ray player to invest in next.

Moving to the main event of playing back actual, native 1080p Blu-ray discs, I dropped in the recent Bond film Casino Royale (Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, Blu-ray). The player played the preview promoting the Blu-ray format nicely, although it hiccupped a few times before spinning the disc, which might have been an HDMI issue with my Classe preamp that ultimately worked itself out. The cobra-fighting scene set in Madagascar (Chapter 2) shows incredible visual detail. The target with the scars on his face looks remarkable, while the greenery in the jungle scene is lush and vibrant. There is a distinct absence of grain that makes me wonder how much better this film could look on the big screen, as opposed to at home on Blu-ray. The pop of orange and red during the crane explosion is still one of the better Blu-ray tests for color fidelity I can think of right now.

Today's reference standard for Blu-ray performance in terms of on screen or via retailers is The Dark Knight (Warner Home Video, Blu-ray), for good reason. This cost-no-object Hollywood franchise keeps outdoing itself with more and more over the top productions based around America's favorite somewhat personally flawed superhero. It took about 60 seconds to get the disc fully playing, which isn't bad by current Blu-ray standards, but it is slow by traditional DVD-Video standards that are likely how mainstream consumers will judge the player's load time. The Dolby TrueHD soundtrack on the now-famous opening bank robbery scene is off-the-charts good. The thumping tightness of the bass on the track is the reason why God created subwoofers. The blasts from the shotgun of the bank executive sound palpable. Visually, the detail on the robber's masks are razor-sharp, but the pasty hues on our first look at the Joker after the school bus busts into the bank is even more impressive in terms of color and detail resolution.

In the Hollywood spoof Tropic Thunder (Paramount Home Entertainment, Blu-ray) I was able to compare the difference between my former Sony BDP-S1 player and the Sony BDP-S5000ES player. There is no question that the ES player is leaps and bounds better. The lushness of the canopy of green trees looks more emerald on the ES player, as it has a slightly grayer tone on the older player. The flesh tones look more lifelike on the BDP-S5000 than on the previous player. Sonically, the crunches of the trees as the cast marches through them sound even crisper and more believable. At every level, the Sony BDP-S5000ES is better than the previous Sony BDP-S1.

The Downside
All too often, we reviewers have to mention a lacking remote and the Sony BDP-S5000ES is yet another case of this. At its price, the player could legitimately offer an RF remote, but if you won't go that far, how about one that is backlit? Blu-ray movies are watched mostly in the dark and, unless you can learn the buttons on the remote by touch, it's hard to control when the lights are down.

It's hard to tell people spending at the top of the food chain why they invest in a disc player that can't play all legacy discs. I guess if this review was of a Samsung or LG Blu-ray player, I would understand the lack of SACD capability, but from Sony? C'mon. I bought more than 100 of these discs and, thanks to the major labels (Sony Music included) refusing to release their back-catalogue music titles in HD music formats like 24-bit 192 kHz stereo or 7.1 HD surround on Blu-ray, you'd think that there would be a legacy life raft floated to those of us who invested in SACD as a format, but no.

Being connected to the Internet is a big plus for keeping your player up to date with the latest firmware and software updates. Burning DVDs and updating players that way has proven to be less than perfect. This said, I would have liked to see the Sony BDP-S5000ES be a wireless device like my new Apple TV. It's a small issue but having fewer cables is better for my system as more and more devices are connecting via wi-fi to the Internet.

Conclusion
The idea that a cheapie Blu-ray player can be the source of your top-performing theater is a flawed concept. The same factors that make your audiophile CD player sound better than the $200 store-bought one apply to Blu-ray as much as they did to top-performing compact disc players in their heyday. The Sony BDP-S5000ES is a solidly-built, well-engineered, well-thought-out, relatively fast-loading player that connects to the Internet via an Ethernet cable to keep your player performing at tip-top levels.

If you have an HDTV over 50 inches and specifically a front video projector-based system, you need a serious Blu-ray player for the front end of your system. The performance difference over my last player is not subtle - it's enough to floor you. The colors are more vibrant. The detail is the best I have ever seen and the audio is superb with Dolby TrueHD and DTS Master Audio. The more time I spent with my new Blu-ray player, the more I thought of the old adage from the Scottish audiophile company Linn. In promoting their legendary LP12 turntable, Linn suggested that your system is only as good as your source. Blu-ray is such a powerful HD format that sometimes we can forget that doing all of the little things right, like building a solid, isolated high-end machine, yields even better performance, because with the Sony BDP-S5000ES that's exactly what you get: one of the two or three best Blu-ray players money can buy in the market today.


Source: HomeTheaterReview

Chrisy

chrisy is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #2 of 4 Old 12-04-09, 01:20 PM
LPS
Shackster
LPSimard
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Canada
Posts: 11
Re: Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review

Interesting review. I quite agree with you about "source limited" systems (I still have my old LP-12). I'm using a Denon DVD-3800BD blu-ray player since about 18 months. Yes, it's very expensive (C$1900 then), but as you said... Anyway, when I got it last year, I did a comparaison with the Sony ES player then available at the store. The Denon was superior to that Sony player (about C$1500 then). The audio & video is very very good. You are righthe audio is superb with Dolby TrueHD and DTS Master Audio formats. The Denon is truly excellent with blu-ray, excellent also when upscalling regular DVD to 1080p. It's a good CD player too.

I did not had the chance to see the 5000ES player you just reviewed, demonstrated in good conditions. However, I suspect, my Denon player and the Sony might be similar in performances. Did you had a chance to compare them? Any experience with the Denon 3800?

Last edited by LPS; 12-04-09 at 01:36 PM. Reason: Add comments...corrections of errors
LPS is offline  
post #3 of 4 Old 05-01-11, 08:13 PM
Senior Shackster
 
Vader's Avatar
Derek
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Colorado
Posts: 402
My System
Re: Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review

Well, I just got my 5000ES (I was at the right time/right place for a fire sale), and I must say that I am extremely impressed with this thing! While it does not have the bevy of new features like the newer players, none of those interested my anyways (ie. Netflix, BDLive, etc). I am interested in one thing: perfect, reliable playback of my BD library, including all features on the disc. So far, so good. Given the fact that the industry is moving more towards a "disposable razor" approach with the newer offerings (cheaper, plastic players that weigh less than the keyboard I am typing this on... so much for solid build quality, huh...? ), IMO this thing ranks as one of the last of a dying breed. Maybe this is an omen as to the fate of physical media as a whole, as streaming seems to be over taking it rather quickly..? Anyway, while I will miss my 05FD, I absolutely love this thing, and do not see it being replaced in the foreseeable future...

Peace... Vader

"Ya see, we plan ahead. That way we don't do anything right now. Earl explained it to me." - Valentine McKee

One sub to rumble them all. One sub to shake them. One sub to humble them all. And in the darkness break them....

The Overlook Theater - Not liable for injuries sustained while laughing.

Last edited by Vader; 05-02-11 at 07:23 AM.
Vader is offline  
post #4 of 4 Old 06-03-11, 03:36 AM
 
SocyFisher's Avatar
SocyFisher
 
Join Date: May 2011
Location: 1360 Amethyst Drive Lansi
Posts: 20
Re: Sony BDP-S5000ES Blu-ray Player Review

I love the fact that it has an easy access/connection on the internet, you can check for software updates anytime. This player is an evidence that blu- ray is now a mature technology with no performance or functional compromises.
SocyFisher is offline  
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
bdp-s5000es , blu-ray , player , reviewed , sony

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now




PLEASE COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED FIELDS BELOW... THANKS!

REQUIRED FIELDS ON THIS PAGE
YOU MUST COMPLETE ALL OF THESE

Username
Password
Confirm Password
Email Address
Confirm Email Address
Random Question
Random Question #2




User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
PLEASE READ BELOW PRIOR TO ENTERING AN EMAIL ADDRESS!

ATTENTION!

YOU MUST ACTIVATE YOUR ACCOUNT!

Activation requires you reply to an email we will send you after you register... if you do not reply to this email, you will not be able to view certain areas of the forum or certain images... nor will you be able download software.

AN INVALID EMAIL ADDRESS WILL CAUSE YOUR ACCOUNT TO BE DELETED!

See our banned email list here: Banned Email List

We DO NOT respond to spamcop, boxtrapper and spamblocker emails... please add @hometheatershack DOT com to your whitelist prior to registering or you will get nowhere on your registration.


Email Address:
OR

Log-in









Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.


Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page



Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML is not allowed!
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

 


For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome