Home Theater Forum and Systems - HomeTheaterShack.com - Reply to Topic

Thread: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now




PLEASE COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED FIELDS BELOW... THANKS!

REQUIRED FIELDS ON THIS PAGE
YOU MUST COMPLETE ALL OF THESE

Username
Password
Confirm Password
Email Address
Confirm Email Address
Random Question
Random Question #2




User Name:
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.

Password:


Confirm Password:
Email Address
PLEASE READ BELOW PRIOR TO ENTERING AN EMAIL ADDRESS!

ATTENTION!

YOU MUST ACTIVATE YOUR ACCOUNT!

Activation requires you reply to an email we will send you after you register... if you do not reply to this email, you will not be able to view certain areas of the forum or certain images... nor will you be able download software.

AN INVALID EMAIL ADDRESS WILL CAUSE YOUR ACCOUNT TO BE DELETED!

See our banned email list here: Banned Email List

We DO NOT respond to spamcop, boxtrapper and spamblocker emails... please add @hometheatershack DOT com to your whitelist prior to registering or you will get nowhere on your registration.


Email Address:
OR

Log-in










  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
02-28-16 08:06 AM
Toffkanda
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

"I did finally weigh it last night... It came in at 52lbs.

I do realize these days that this isn't a "big" sub, but it really fits my liking (I'm more of a music guy). I was happy with three subs performing on this level. I've heard theaters with massive subs that would make shut doors sound like their repeatedly getting slammed shut and did not like it. That said, this is plenty big enough and the quality of bass is quite good"

52 pounds! I worked with a pair of 12 inch drivers recently each 31 pounds unpacked. Yours is an admirably lightweight sub. I live in a world where its seen as crazy to build a 16cuft soundbox. People are only truly amazed when small boxes do great things. Then again the general perception of good bass is the punchy 40-80hz range. For me I tend towards drivers suitable for flat FR down to 20hz (with a bit of infrasonics) in boxes of around 2cuft. A sonosub is a small footprint setup. It would have been beautiful if you could have two in your new home for smoother room response and a little bit more SPL.
02-26-16 06:11 PM
yamahaSHO
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Thank you again. I was pretty focused on making it look good as well as sound good. Since I'll be moving and giving up a theater, I will move this into a living room setting in the new house and need my wife to approve of a sub sitting in the living room. I will be going from 3 subs to 1, which will be tough, but I'll get over it if I can get it place well. I did have high hopes from the sub driver seeing how it performed in a less than stellar box from Klipsch (plastic creaking and LOTS of port chuff), but was really happy that it turned out as well as it did. If I ever get my hands on a driver from an RT-12d, I might swap that in and see how it does. I did finally weigh it last night... It came in at 52lbs.

I do realize these days that this isn't a "big" sub, but it really fits my liking (I'm more of a music guy). I was happy with three subs performing on this level. I've heard theaters with massive subs that would make shut doors sound like their repeatedly getting slammed shut and did not like it. That said, this is plenty big enough and the quality of bass is quite good.

My sub turns out to be about the same height as an SVS PC12-Plus, so in light of moving, I was able to get a box for it to more easily transport it.



Just a comparison shot of a sub my dad and I build a little over 20 years ago. Not really a "sub", but it does put out some good bass and we copied a Bose Accoustimass module (measured a clear model in stores) and made it bigger with bigger drivers. About 5 years ago, I cut out the back, upgraded the drivers, the port, and put a plate amp on it.
02-26-16 07:48 AM
Toffkanda
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Excellent build, exquisite finishing! This is one of the most profitable outcomes I've seen, my criteria for profitability being as low an extension in as small a volume as possible with reasonable SPL and musicality achieved in the process. That's a novice talking!
I didn't think an old 13 pound 12 inch driver in a 4cuft enclosure could go flat to 14 hz. I thought you needed sophisticated drivers for that. Personally I have a great bias for ported low extension.
Your DIY Sub provokes envy.
02-23-16 08:21 PM
yamahaSHO
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Thank you Toffkanda. I can't say for sure, but I'd imagine the larger the box, the more cone movement you'll get for a given amount of power. As far as WinISD, I didn't have any data on the driver, so I winged it a bit. But with the data, it should be able to predict subwoofer behavior. The BASH amp I use has an ~18hz HPF and the tune is between 19-20hz, which does help with keeping the woofer from getting out of control below the tuning point.
02-01-16 09:13 AM
Toffkanda
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

The tube volume is a bit big compared to the volume of the RW-12d box, go easy on the sub until you find its limits, especially with the default subsonic filter on the Bash 300 which is 17.7 hz.][/QUOTE]

[IIRC, the volume difference between this and the RW-12d box is ~1cu/ft. Curiousity has me wondering what'll do in this box. The original one chuffed and creaked too much. I always go easy on things until I get a good feel of them.][/QUOTE]

Hello Jason, Mike P,,
Please pardon my digression and I know this thread has been long in the making (and a very lovely job too!) but I would want to know more about the worries when box volume is larger than usual. Is it overexcursion with bottoming out? If so can't WinISD predict this on the cone excursion plot? What about EBS and LLT designs? Is low tuning sufficient protection or do you have to worry about how far you can go on the amp?
01-30-16 01:44 PM
yamahaSHO
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Back from the dead...

Okay, so it's been 5 years and I just finally took the base plate off to finish it. The sub was mostly hidden and sounds good, so I never got around to finishing the base plate. Since I'll be moving this year, I won't be doing a theater again as it hardly ever got used. I sold off a good bit of my stuff, including my SVS subs but I am hanging on to this as I'll need at least one sub in the living room and I think this one looks so much better and performed just a good as the SVS I had.

Anyway, I actually work with someone from this board that had some DuraTex left over from his builds and since I didn't need a bunch, I 'borrowed' some from him. It took a few more coats than I wanted, but getting the stuff to stick to the drywall spackle from a few filled holes and getting a good finish took a little bit of time.

Before:





After:







11-30-13 09:36 PM
yamahaSHO
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

I was not, but it appears my driver behaves a lot like an older Infinity Kappa Perfect.
11-30-13 06:46 PM
Warlock Lord I think I've found myself in a similar situation. my amp on a Klipsch sub-12 appears to seen its last movie. I'm thinking of taking the driver out and constructing a sonosub. were you ever able to find the Klipsch driver properties for modeling?
10-27-13 03:02 AM
Jasonpctech
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Still lovin my Dayton, Titanic based sono. Glad yours is rockin.
10-27-13 01:56 AM
yamahaSHO
Re: Klipsch driver stuffed in a Sonotube

Quote:
ProCast12's wrote: View Post
You def. Blew the coil. Its starting to unwind.. it will still play but will have a rattling noise.. try the other sub and you will see it should be fine... I've heard this problem in a pt of car audio subs... good luck. Hope this helps
Just wanted to update this. I finally, years later, just replaced the original driver in this sonosub. I didn't do it because of any issue, but I put some small dents in the metal dust cap when I was building it and bought a new driver directly after. I got tired of the spare, new driver, sitting around and decided I would replace and sell the old one. I didn't take the old one apart, but for years it had performed well and when I got it out, I played with the cone a little compressing the suspension and nothing. It felt perfectly normal and no noises. I think that something may had gotten into the magnet/cone/coil area during building but has since been dislodged.

Anyway, I don't know why I wanted to update this, but it worked/works awesome!
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML is not allowed!

 


For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome