Home Theater Forum and Systems banner

Off The Shelf Screen Paint

19139 Views 17 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  Philnick
10
We are getting close to a selection, and it is narrowed down to 2 candidates:
Sherwin Williams Duration Extra White (Matte)
PPG Diamond Base 1 (flat white)

Our Behr Silver Screen / White Opal Pearl is just too dark. These white paints really show the details better, especially skin tones.
Our projector is the Epson 5050UB, and the Blu-ray player is the Panasonic DP-UB820. Surprisingly, these paints also do well with black level detail.

We have three sample boards on the left, PPG Diamond. The 4 sample boards on the right are SW Duration.

The boards (sheetrock) are sitting on bar stools and chairs. Sheets are draped over the chairs to hide them.

Let's look at some screen shots!
173918


173919


173920


173921


173922


173923


173924


173925


173926


173927
See less See more
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
4
And a couple more shots, to illustrate the lack of "Hot-Spotting" issues with the Sherwin Williams Duration Extra White Matte paint. Taken with all lights out, using the flash on my Leica Camera.
173937


173938


173939


173940
See less See more
2
And more shots, to show the black level ability...

173941


173942
See less See more
8
My SW Duration Screen (OTS)


Okay...here we go.


Just finished everything up, and my paint crew spent part of the last 4 days here. From set up, building the paint booth, spraying two heavy coats each of the first 3 days (6 coats total, almost 2 gallons), and take down / clean up / detail touch up, to finish the work today.

The sprayer is an electric pro model, and they run around $4000. A spray wand was employed, with a .13 tip. The paint was not reduced with water, and the pressure used was 2500 psi.
No overlap coats. None. And my painter did one continuous spray application...he did not employ a start / stop method.

For those of you who have not followed this paint exploration, you might look here first to see what got me to this point. It actually started when I taped several sheets of white cardboard on my Behr SS / *** screen, and saw the results.
https://www.avsforum.com/forum/110-d...-vs-satin.html

So in the end we chose the SW Duration Extra White, 2 gallons of Matte, and one gallon of Flat. In that 2 to 1 ratio. Strictly off-the-shelf, and very simple.

There is absolutely zero hot spotting! None at all! And the black level is about as good as it was with my Behr SS.

Doing this myself was not an option. Hiring a professional crew, with professional equipment, was my only choice. If you are good at paint rolling, or spraying, you could do this and save the money on labor. This paint can be rolled or sprayed.

This is a "one size fits all" paint. If you have a light controlled room, and want something simple, this is your solution. Off-the-shelf, no complicated mix, no fuss, readily available at your local Sherwin-Williams store. This works with 720P, 1080P, 4K. We even have an older JVC S-VHS player that looks pretty good on this screen!

We are very pleased with the results.
The hardware includes a new Epson 5050UB, a Panasonic DP-UB820, and a Yamaha CX-A5200 AV Pre-Amp Processor. Note the Epson 5050UB is set at Cinema mode (3rd brightest). In Dynamic, it is much brighter. Also, we are on the mid-power level, to extend the lamp life.
173945


173946


173947


173948


173949


173950


173951


173952
See less See more
3
You can "feel" the heat as the Shuttle lifts off!
173953


173954


173955
See less See more
9
Here is a good video, with lots of detail, and dark scenes.
173957


173958


173959


173960


173961


173962


173963


173964


173965
See less See more
I need to mention that the screen shots above, taken from "Gladiator", were shot with ambient light in the room. Not bright lighting, but enough to walk around and not stumble into something (or someone).
This screen paint does fairly well, even with brighter lighting.
3
Here are a couple photos showing how this screen does in a brightly illuminated room.
173966


173967


173968
See less See more
thanks so much for all the great photos
  • Like
Reactions: 1
thanks so much for all the great photos
You are quite welcome. This off-the-shelf paint is nothing short of stunning for its ability to reflect what the film director intended. Rich detail, even when the lights are on. Plus it does not sacrifice black levels, which was a huge surprise to me.
My projector, an Epson 5050UB, is on a rear shelf with a throw / zoom distance of nearly 25 feet. That puts the projected image at a disadvantage as a full 30% of the brightness is lost.
If you are planning to make a room into a multi-purpose media/theater room, with less than perfect lighting, this paint will work just fine.
We are thrilled with this screen.
Glad you enjoyed the photos!
With 100 different paint formulas for the do-it-yourself crowd, you have picked out the simplest basic white color and the easiest to apply that is out there on the market, with outstanding results. It really is a waste of time to look any further to have a screen paint that's going to give any better results than what you have.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
With 100 different paint formulas for the do-it-yourself crowd, you have picked out the simplest basic white color and the easiest to apply that is out there on the market, with outstanding results. It really is a waste of time to look any further to have a screen paint that's going to give any better results than what you have.
The best thing is this paint can be rolled. If you can work a roller, you can paint a screen. All of my test sample boards were rolled with a 1/4 inch nap roller. But we chose to spray, as that sometimes will give a more smooth finish.

We did use 2 gallons of Extra White Matte, mixed with one gallon of flat. That gave us the perfect balance of screen gain, with no hot-spotting issues.

This is a 155 inch diagonal screen, in 16X9 format. A smaller screen could get by with much less paint. We actually had a gallon left over.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Well, you talked me into it. I'm going to buy the SW Duration Extra White in Matte, 1 qt. and try it out on my extra piece of sign board.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Well, you talked me into it. I'm going to buy the SW Duration Extra White in Matte, 1 qt. and try it out on my extra piece of sign board.
Great! Let us know how it works out for you.
We are getting close to a selection, and it is narrowed down to 2 candidates:
Sherwin Williams Duration Extra White (Matte)
PPG Diamond Base 1 (flat white)

Our Behr Silver Screen / White Opal Pearl is just too dark. These white paints really show the details better, especially skin tones.
Our projector is the Epson 5050UB, and the Blu-ray player is the Panasonic DP-UB820. Surprisingly, these paints also do well with black level detail.

We have three sample boards on the left, PPG Diamond. The 4 sample boards on the right are SW Duration.

The boards (sheetrock) are sitting on bar stools and chairs. Sheets are draped over the chairs to hide them.

Let's look at some screen shots!
View attachment 173918

View attachment 173919

View attachment 173920

View attachment 173921

View attachment 173922

View attachment 173923

View attachment 173924

View attachment 173925

View attachment 173926

View attachment 173927
I took your recommendation and painted my 4x8 foot MDF. Board with Sherwin Williams duration super white matte, and I could not be happier. Quart cost 30 Canadian dollars and made a huge improvement in colors,black levels with plenty brightness and no hot spotting.
I am using a Sony l.cd. projector 720 p. From around 2008. With h.d.m.l. blu ray look terrific and lowly d.v.d s even look good,
Thanks so much !
  • Like
Reactions: 1
So glad it worked for you! We are very happy with ours.
Sherwin Williams Duration Home Interior Acrylic Latex Matte worked well for me.
I've been using this site's Cream&Sugar recipes since July of 2008. The original recipe when I bought my Panasonic PT-AE2000 1080p projector - which served me well for almost ten years until my basement theater was demolished to repair the main support beam across the basement theater. When I rebuilt the theater room in 2019 with a higher ceiling and JVC's DLA-RS1000 (a/k/a DLA-NX5) entry-level true 4K projector, I painted an entire 14' by 8' high wall with Cream&Sugar Ultra, the final version of the recipe before Harpmaker and crew stopped maintaining that project. (I've always painted my screen with a roller, since there's no ventilation in my theater.)

Cream&Sugar Ultra is also an off-the-shelf.mix,half and half flat white Valspar latex paiantn and Basics Acrylic Silver paint.

My projected area is 11'4" by 6' - 17x9, with a diagonal of 154" - pretty similar to yours.

My throw distance is 15' 9" - as far back as I could get in my room, so I'm using the largest zoom the projector can do.

Interesting tip - photographers know that all but the most expensive "constant aperture" zooms let more light through at their wide angle end than their telephoto end, so you get more light with the projector closer and using the widest angle on your zoom, instead of further back and more towards the telephoto end.

One unpublicized advantage of our painted screens is that the plane of polarization of active-shutter 3D glasses doesn't matter, since the screen disperses the projector's polarization.

My Blu-ray player is one of the last Oppo UDP-203s sold, ordered right after they put up their "Goodbye" screen on April 1, 2018. I considered the Panny you have in 2019 before rebuilding my theater, when I read about its ability to be set to match projector brightness, but then JVC released a free firmware update that added frame-by-frame dynamic tone matching based not on metadata but on actually analyzing the incoming images and adjusting on-the-fly, so I stuck with the Oppo.
See less See more
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top