Home Theater Forum and Systems banner

1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I have been very lazy about posting a review on these speakers but I decided I should not put it off any longer..

The short and sweet version of my review: These speakers have amazing detail and resolution, and blow away the competition at their price range... The value is camouflaged by more recognizable brands, a true diamond in the rough. I think they are also very much improved over their predecessor (Dana 630) which already had glowing reviews..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #2
Now for the long-winded version.. a.k.a. my "journey" to decide on these speakers...

My dad has always appreciated classical music above all other types and I've wanted to get him new speakers for a few years now.. I have poured through hundreds, possibly thousands of posts here and over at AVS on my quest to find speakers that my dad would absolutely love...

A while back I came across this thread: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1341386
in which there was a very detailed comparison between the Swan Customs and the Dana 640is... as well as quite a few others giving great reviews for the 640is..

One particular review went into great depth and the reviewer touched upon a lot of what I was looking for.. "On the 640is, I go, "Holy , I'm THERE! There's the acoustic bass, there's the piano, there's the singers, a guitar, a cello, and all the space between them..." No speakers, just music. .... As for the bass response, I'm floored by it. "

I was hooked, but not convinced. Also, the price of the 640is were a bit out of my budget, so I focused more on the 630i. I did tons of research... I tried to find any information on the internet about the Dana series, even the predecessors and found lots of positive remarks.

One particular article helped to convince me this was a wise investment... even though it was about it's predecessor, the Dana 630, it was very impressive. Essentially it was a blind shootout of various high end monitors: http://www.affordableaudio.org/aa2007-10.pdf

A few remarks stood out:
-"Bass was tight, and dynamics, both micro and macro, were very good.
Vocals got very high marks for clarity, and instruments for accuracy. Most of the panel thought the
630’s were a very good loudspeaker, with excellent overall balance... Winner: Dana 630 67.19 points to B&W 805S 65.27 points"

-"It wasn’t until much later that people started to realize that the $349 Dana model 630 had stood toe
to toe with the $2500 B&W 805S" ---> This impressed me to no end... how could speakers selling for $349 do better than speakers selling for $2,500?!!

Now, I know the retail price for the revised version (630i) is quite a bit more than $349... but again, I believe that it is much improved over the already great 630...

Another thing that influenced me to buy the 630is is the great customer service that I have received from Jon Lane at the Audio insider. I am in no way affiliated with them whatsoever, I am just simply a very happy and loyal customer. I previously bought Swan active desktop speakers after careful deliberation and was very happy with them.

When I found out about a special project in which Jon Lane was personally involved in the design and many iterations of tweaking, fine-tuning the crossover I was intrigued- the Arx A5 project. It took quite a bit of convincing (and endless research), but I joined the first group buy and am eagerly, patiently waiting to receive them this summer. He has been very accommodating and transparent about many aspects of the project and the group buy, and actually values and acts on feedback from everybody from the audio enthusiasts to first-time speaker buyers. That is rare and something to be appreciated when buying internet direct... Anyways, my journey with Arx is a different journey I will talk about in another thread once I've actually received them and had time to spend with them...

Back to the Dana 630is: I've hunted all over for the unboxing pictures I took, but can't find them unfortunately. In summary, they were packaged very well, and also double boxed. Arrived in pristine condition and I was pleasantly surprised when I saw the wood cherry grain the first time in person- beautiful, fine craftsmanship.

Naturally, I was very curious about these speakers so had a super-extended "break-in period" to get them ready for set up at my dad's house. I was impressed but not blown away initially, but after a couple days of breaking them in, the sound became what I had read in the various glowing reviews... I was confident I had made the right choice. As I listened to more and more music I found myself not wanting to let go of them. I enjoy classical music, but it's nowhere near my favorite genres.. I knew from the reviews that they would be great for classical, but I was truly impressed by how the speakers handled everything I threw at it. I also had extended listening sessions just as 2.0 as well as 2.1 connected with a HP Seaton Submersive sub.. I was surprised at the amount of bass these speakers could produce by themselves and also how wonderful they sounded when integrated with the sub. (Using my Denon 4311ci, I tried both 60hz and 80hz crossovers; both integrated the Danas with the SubM very well)

I integrated them into my home theater setup at one point and kept them as my main L and R speakers for over a month because they did great with movies as well.. I thought i would run into sound stage issues integrating them with a different brand center (SVS SCS-01) but the sound stage only improved..


So the icing on the cake, and the most rewarding experience with the 630is by far: I finally, recently hooked them up at my dad's house. The first album I put on for him was a classical album he's heard hundreds of times and he was absolutely floored by what he's been missing from listening in his car (which had the "premium" speaker option) and from older speakers that these 630is replaced in his living room. The look on his face was precious, and he must have listened to various albums for hours and hours after I had left as he was falling in love with his music all over again..

As a side note, I was also surprised that the soundstage grew much larger.. I expected it a little since my living room is much smaller than his, but the way the music enveloped the room put a huge smile on my face... anyways, I've rambled on much longer than folks care to read, so I'll end my review :)


I'll give a preemptive disclaimer about my review: I did not take any measurements, and set up the Dana 630is on SVS floorstands about a foot away from any major boundaries, with a slight toe-in to the main listening position; I tried "pure direct" mode on my receiver as well as calibrating with Audyssey MultiEQ XT32 with some additional fine-tuning afterwards.

I realize that my review may not be as technical as plenty others posted on this forum, but did my best to convey my journey in deciding on them and how I feel about their performance. I will say that I have auditioned many, many speakers ranging from low-end to super high-end for the past 20 years since I first really fell in love with this hobby at the age of 9.. so for me to give such a great review of these speakers is really something... at least in my humble opinion :T
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #3 (Edited)
I forgot to post a picture of the 630i speakers .. this one is borrowed from the audio insider website since I can't find the memory card that has my unboxing pictures... if I find it I will post them as the stock photo doesn't really show how nice the cherry wood grain is up close and personal against a real background..
 

Attachments

·
HTS Moderator , Reviewer
Joined
·
3,367 Posts
I have about a half dozen subwoofer reviews on HTS, so I guess that qualifies me to respond... :D

That was a nice review. It was short on technical details -- and even the listening assessment -- but it was quite clear you were very smitten by those speakers. I certainly didn't need to read between the lines to know how happy you and your father were with that purchase, which is really what this hobby is all about.

I'm glad everything worked out for you, and your efforts were duly rewarded it seems. I hope those speakers keep that smile on your fathers face for a long time to come.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
Thanks Jim.. looking back at my posts I realize they were equally about my journey on deciding on them just as much as it was a review for the speakers themselves. I probably should have titled my thread to reflect that, but I can't change it now...

I've read and enjoyed quite a few of your reviews here (as well as your budget sub thread, and various posts and reviews over at AVS) and they are obviously much more thorough than mine. You put in a lot of effort to break out the reviews into various sections for easier reference and go into a lot more detail for the listening assessment...

With the Dana 630is, I gravitated towards an informal-style review since I felt like I didn't really analyze them enough for a formal review... and by that I mean I wasn't taking detailed notes when listening to music or watching movies, etc. Although I did take the time to try out different configurations and crossovers, I knew the speakers would eventually be going to my dad's house so I spent more time just simply enjoying them and using them as I would normally day-to-day.

I think when I do get my Arx A5s, A2, and A1bs (which will be replacing my existing living room home theater speakers) and have had time to do some critical listening I will put forth the effort to write up a review closer to your caliber.

Anyways, thanks for your post, it is appreciated :)
 

·
HTS Moderator , Reviewer
Joined
·
3,367 Posts
I've read and enjoyed quite a few of your reviews here (as well as your budget sub thread, and various posts and reviews over at AVS) and they are obviously much more thorough than mine. You put in a lot of effort to break out the reviews into various sections for easier reference and go into a lot more detail for the listening assessment...
Thank you. Yes, they do take a considerable amount of time to create. The unfortunate by-product of being compulsive I suppose. :heehee:


With the Dana 630is, I gravitated towards an informal-style review since I felt like I didn't really analyze them enough for a formal review... and by that I mean I wasn't taking detailed notes when listening to music or watching movies, etc. Although I did take the time to try out different configurations and crossovers, I knew the speakers would eventually be going to my dad's house so I spent more time just simply enjoying them and using them as I would normally day-to-day.

I think when I do get my Arx A5s, A2, and A1bs (which will be replacing my existing living room home theater speakers) and have had time to do some critical listening I will put forth the effort to write up a review closer to your caliber.
You should write up your reviews however you see fit - there's no saying my style is any better or worse then the next persons. Frankly, I wish more would do write-ups; I think they provide a significant benefit. Often people have the same type of thoughts you do, but they never type them out for everyone else to see. That's a shame too.

Whatever you decide to write about the Arx's just make certain it's in your own style, whatever you choose it to be. I'll certainly read it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
Thanks Jim. I certainly will... but I know already that I will be doing a lot more critical listening since i plan on having these speakers for a very long time.... I am so excited for the Arx A5 speakers...
 

·
HTS Moderator , Reviewer
Joined
·
3,367 Posts
Have the A5's been released yet? Last I heard they still weren't a shipping product, but admittedly I haven't looked in a few months.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
The A5 has not been officially released yet. There has been a great sense of community among interested buyers with various questions, feedback and suggestions for the A5 on the audio insider forums, many which are on either one of the two Group Buy lists and an additional waiting list. I have really enjoyed being part of that community. (as well as being one of the lucky 20 members in Group Buy 1) In my opinion , Jon Lane of The Audio Insider has been doing a great job interacting with and truly valuing that community while working hard to bring multiple products to fruition.

There were a few delays from the supplier and also the factory building the speakers; as far as I know they are not slated to hit stateside until late June/July. Delays are always tough on vendors especially when they are out of their control..

In my opinion, the Arx community should be (and for the most part are I think) patient and understanding as they should realize there are many moving parts involved in bringing a new product to life... everything from the tremendous amount of time spent designing and tweaking it to getting all the necessary supplies and factory build out on schedule, as well as ocean freight times... Besides all that, keeping in mind that it still has yet to be officially released is important as well.

Anyways, an admittedly long answer to your question, but the above thoughts were on my mind...
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top