Sorry to hear nothings working for you!
Probably best to wait until the new subs arrive at this stage..
Spikes on a sub will generally help to give a cleaner/tighter bass, but I don't think it's going to help your extreme null at the listening position..
My guess would be that the particle board flooring is maybe causing a problem..That's not a normal flooring board..
That being the case, you may need to put something solid under the subs, like a concrete slab or similar..
I finished up putting a sand filled box under my sub., with a layer of that sheet packing plastic/ foam on top (can't remember the correct name for it) before I could get a smooth extension to the lower frequencies..with minimum peaks and dips..
I hope the new subs. work out better for you..