Home Theater Forum and Systems banner

1 - 3 of 3 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Can anybody explain why a tower speaker is superior compared to in-wall or in-ceiling opinions? Obviously, the latter two are easier on the pocket but what is it in their construction that makes them the less than stellar pick? Is it the lack of enclosure, off axis?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
With towers/floor standing speakers, the distance of midrange from the floor is considered. With in wall speakers, that is not the case and manufacturers do not know the surfaces where the sound will bounce off. As for the enclosure, it is also unsure what the enclosure size will be behind the speakers. There are more factors to consider though, some of which you can familiarize yourself with by the latter part of this read.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,034 Posts
Can anybody explain why a tower speaker is superior compared to in-wall or in-ceiling opinions? Obviously, the latter two are easier on the pocket but what is it in their construction that makes them the less than stellar pick? Is it the lack of enclosure, off axis?
Well...as mentioned, enclosure size for any high quality speaker is calculated for the best performance. With IW and IC speakers almost all of them are built with in infinite baffle design. Some DO come with backer boxes, but mostly those are for sound insulation to keep from bleeding to other rooms, and seldom made as a calculated enclosure.
Another problem is that many of the IW/IC speakers available are made with cheap junk drivers and sold as builder specials, where they’re made cheap so a contractor can offer them as an inclusive to a customers new home build. Also. Very few of the manufacturers publish any specs, and they’re hard to review since installing and in-installing to review other IW speakers is NOT a simple task. This means that you don’t really know if the speaker has a good XO network to deal with baffle step compensation(different for IW) and transition from tweeter to woofer.
Towers(and ** speakers) also have the advantage of placement. Toe in and spacing from wall boundaries are key to great performance. Can’t do that with IW speakers, and IC speakers are just wrong considering where the sound is supposed to come from. Triad is a company that makes IC speakers that are very high quality and can combat the issue of sound from the ceiling.
Quality towers also have an advantage of generally higher sensitivity so they’re easier to drive. They normally have much higher quality components. And with larger, and usually more drivers, the speaker can handle thermal and power loads better.
Anyway, that a few things I could quickly think of.
FWIW, IC and IW have their place, and if the right ones are chosen, can make for a very good experience. They won’t be cheap though, and high quality ones can easily rival good towers in price.
 
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Top