Home Theater Forum and Systems banner
Cancel

Speaker Settings..Large Or Small...The Great Debate

41128 Views 36 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  WilliamSmith, 
Prof.
Over the years there has been a lot of debate over which speaker settings should be used with MCACC on Pioneer Receivers..
Pioneer (and some Audiophiles) have always recommended setting ALL speakers to SMALL..Crossover to 80Hz. and Subwoofer to YES..Of course there can be variations in the xover setting, which is dependent on the room and speaker requirements.

If one selects THX in the speaker settings, then the xover is automatically set to 80Hz..

For the most part..these are the settings that most people use..myself included..

The SMALL setting for the speakers is not determined by the physical size of the speakers, but relates to the frequency range that is handled by the front and surround speakers..
When the SMALL setting is selected, frequencies below 80Hz.(if that's the xover point used) are directed to the SW to ease the bass load on the front speakers..thereby improving the quality of reproduction from the front speakers.
This is their reasoning for using these settings...and it sounds quite logical..

The other side of the debate is that you don't need to use the SMALL setting, particularly if you have floor-standers for your fronts, because the bass drivers are quite capable of handling the lower frequencies at high volume levels and peaks without stress...There are even a number of small speakers these days, that are quite capable of handling low bass frequencies without difficulty..

My feeling is that the reason Pioneer in making their recommendations, are trying to cover all aspects of speaker performance within a wide range of speaker quality..

Individual owners of Pionneer AVR's who have used settings other than those recommended, have said that they prefer the sound performance of the settings they have made..Namely, changing the speaker setting from SMALL to LARGE..
Changing the SW setting from YES to PLUS allows lower bass frequencies ( below the xover cut off point) to be handled by both the fronts and the sub,,In some ways, it's actually providing more emphasis to the bass, particularly upper bass which is generally produced more by the LCR speakers than the sub..

One thing that I've found annoying at times is the lack of power and dynamics of orchestral theme music, played during the movie in both DVD's and Blu-rays..
This is certainly not the case with some movies..In particular the opening Star Wars theme and some other well known movies.
.
I watch a lot of Sci-Fi and Action/ Adventure type movies, where there's always dramatic theme music and similar dynamic music played through the movie..
On occasions, that music sounds a bit "thin"..lacking body and oomph! when it is obvious that the movie at that point requires full bodied dynamic sound..
I've always put it down to post-production control variations between different studio's, but of late I started to question whether my audio system was performing at it's best..Namely my MCACC settings..

I have always been an advocate of following the recommended settings..ALL SMALL..Xover 80Hz. SW..YES..So I decided to bite the bullet and try some other settings..

I set the fronts to LARGE..Surrounds I left at SMALL and left xover at 80Hz..and set the SW to PLUS..I left the calibration for that pre-set as it was previously done..

I first switched on HDTV and immediately noticed that male voices sounded "fuller".. for want of a better word..I certainly couldn't tell if there were any other improvements because of their highly compressed audio signal..

I then put in a Blu-ray movie to get a better idea of any further improvements..I played "The Prince of Persia"..This is one movie where I felt that the orchestral theme was a bit thin..and was the type of music and movie that really needed some power and dynamics..I mean it sounded alright, but just lacked something..
Well, the opening theme blew me away this time!! It was full and enveloping for the first time..just like I expected it should sound.. with very clear drum beats and the individual instruments coming through strongly..What you might call full bodied!..and all through the movie the music sounded richer..

I then decided to play a Star Wars movie, wondering if that theme music would show any improvement..It did!!
Again..that music had even more body to it than I had ever heard before!

I've now played a number of my movies and have noticed significant improvements in some, while others just seem slightly better..for what ever reason..

I'm sure there are some audio systems which may perform better on the recommended settings, but if you feel that there is something lacking with your current MCACC settings, then I strongly urge you to try some other settings..You may be surprised at the results..
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
21 - 37 of 37 Posts
Wayne A. Pflughaupt

Hey Mark,


Mark Techer said:
Please correct me if I am wrong. Is the THX HPF (80Hz and up) not a 12dB/oct slope? Is the design not to work with the acoustic roll-off of THX speakers at 80Hz (typically 12dB/oct for sealed box) to become a 24dB slope?
Click to expand...
Don’t know much about THX myself, but according to this site it’s 24 dB. Not saying that’s gospel; it’s just the first thing I hit when I Googled “thx high pass.”


Prof's room (like my own) is small. I am not sure how the difference between 80Hz (HPF'd) and a natural acoustic roll off is so night and day.
Click to expand...
I think it probably would be at audible. Anytime you cascade two filters on top of each other, the roll-out slopes combine for a steeper slope. I don’t see how it could be any different if one of the “filters” is acoustic. After all, the speaker can’t “ignore” the effect of the electronic filter.

In any event, actual extension with the speakers set for small vs. large would be easy enough to check with a sine wave at something like 80 Hz or perhaps a bit lower, and an SPL meter. If there is no change in a small vs. large reading, then the filter is having no audible effect.


I wonder if Prof experimented with lowering the crossover from the THX 80Hz default back to 50Hz, rather than bi-pass HPF'ing altogether?
Click to expand...
Theoretically, if move the crossover point far enough beyond the speaker’s actual bass output, the effect should be inaudible.

Regards,
Wayne
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
I wonder if Prof experimented with lowering the crossover from the THX 80Hz default back to 50Hz, rather than bi-pass HPF'ing altogether?
Click to expand...
Mark..I haven't tried dropping the xover down to 50Hz. but I don't understand the reasoning for that..
The front speaker roll-off starts around 75dB..so output is diminishing below that frequency..On the other hand the subs xover setting of 80Hz. leaves a gap between the two..
For a smooth transition of frequencies around the xover point..does there not need to be a reasonable overlap of frequencies between the two speakers like any speaker design?
I realise that the xover is not a brick wall and frequencies from fronts and sub are still within those xover points..
but obviously will have an effect on voices and instruments which fall within that gap..

If the sub xover is lowered further to 50Hz. then surely that gap is further increased..for frequencies in that range..:scratch:
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
ISLAND1000 said:
My Pioneer VSX23TXH has additional frequency shaping capability which I use depending on the mains that I use. I make changes to the EQ while in the MCACC setup particularly in the area of the SW crossover. In addition after MCACC has been completed I make pluses and minuses using the "tone" controls ie: bass treble + plus or - minus 6, settings. The frequency adjustments with the Pioneer receiver are almost limitless . . . . below 63Hz.
Click to expand...
I presume you mean above 63Hz., because the 63Hz. adjustment is only operational if you have your speakers set to LARGE..
Reply
Save
Like
ISLAND1000
Yes!
Reply
Save
Like
Mark Techer
Prof. said:
Mark..I haven't tried dropping the xover down to 50Hz. but I don't understand the reasoning for that..
Click to expand...
If you think that running a band limited satellite sounds better full range than HPF at 80Hz, then lowering that crossover means that your not feeding the 20Hz ~ 50Hz into a an LCRs that is clearly not designed to play full range signals. This way you should get the 'benefit' you believe your getting with risking overload to the drivers. All you will be doing is filtering frequencies to the LCR that you can't hear (because the speaker doesn't play them loud enough) anyway.

The front speaker roll-off starts around 75dB..so output is diminishing below that frequency..On the other hand the subs xover setting of 80Hz. leaves a gap between the two..
Click to expand...
Not quite. SUB = 20~80. LCRs = 50(75)~20K. If anything, you have a slight overlap, not a hole. The result should be the same as the full range sound without the risk of feeding excessive deep bass to the LCRs.

For a smooth transition of frequencies around the xover point..does there not need to be a reasonable overlap of frequencies between the two speakers like any speaker design?
Click to expand...
Not according to THX whose LCRs F3 point is 80Hz at 12dB/oct which is then combined with the 12dB active crossover providing a total 24dB slope. The fact that your speakers extend that bit below is trivial because there are some THX certified speakers that go to 50Hz.
I realise that the xover is not a brick wall and frequencies from fronts and sub are still within those xover points..
but obviously will have an effect on voices and instruments which fall within that gap..
Click to expand...
It is not a gap, it a slight overlap, so if anything, it should behave as if the mid bass was pushed slightly.

If the sub xover is lowered further to 50Hz. then surely that gap is further increased..for frequencies in that range..:scratch:
Click to expand...
If you lowered the SW LPF to 50Hz, then yes, you could create a "hole" because of the lower limit of the LCRs.

Question is, can you even select different frequencies?
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
Mark Techer said:
Not quite. SUB = 20~80. LCRs = 50(75)~20K. If anything, you have a slight overlap, not a hole. The result should be the same as the full range sound without the risk of feeding excessive deep bass to the LCRs.
Click to expand...
Doh!..that was my stupid mistake..I was looking at it from the wrong direction..of course there is a slight overlap..:whistling:

It is not a gap, it a slight overlap, so if anything, it should behave as if the mid bass was pushed slightly.
Click to expand...
And that push is further enhanced when I raise the xover to 100Hz..

Question is, can you even select different frequencies?
Click to expand...
Only in MCACC..
Reply
Save
Like
Mark Techer
Is this thread name really correct? Should it not be "Setting Speakers Large Or Small - The Great Debate!" ? I am sure there would be many Audyssey owners out there that also argue the point.

I am a fan of BM and always have been. What is funny to me now is the look on a guys face that believed his sales guy when he bought his system. He had an Onkyo THX certified AVR and Krix D'Appolitos for the L and R fronts. The sales guys had set it up for him with the main speakers as large (as the Krix were floor standing) and he wondered why he could only ever turn the volume up to about -10dB without audible cone strain. I suggested that he use his bass management and of course he questioned that because it conflicted with the advice of the sales guy. So I went into his set up menu and set his speakers to small, then played back the same piece of video he'd just showed me. With speakers set to small, I was able to push the volume to 00dB reference with no issue and his jaw hit the ground. And it is purely a case of preventing the drivers in the L and R from having to deal with the huge excursions required to reproduce deep bass. Sending those signals to a purpose built bass speaker (AKA Sub-woofer) did exactly what it was supposed to do - lower distortion and increase dynamic range.
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
vann_d
An interesting article by Secrets of Home Theater and Hi Fi

www.hometheaterhifi.com/volume_12_2/feature-article-slope-troubles-6-2005.html

Copy and paste into browser. Sorry I'm posting from my phone and don't know how to create links...

Nevermind, the link worked!
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
Mark Techer said:
Is this thread name really correct? Should it not be "Setting Speakers Large Or Small - The Great Debate!" ? I am sure there would be many Audyssey owners out there that also argue the point.
Click to expand...
That's a good point Mark..I hadn't considered Audyssey owners being in the same situation..and I guess there are a lot more owners of Audyssey systems on this forum than MCACC systems..
I will change the thread title..
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
vann_d said:
An interesting article by Secrets of Home Theater and Hi Fi

www.hometheaterhifi.com/volume_12_2/feature-article-slope-troubles-6-2005.html

Copy and paste into browser. Sorry I'm posting from my phone and don't know how to create links...

Nevermind, the link worked!
Click to expand...
Thanks for the article..That was a very interesting read..
Reply
Save
Like
Prof.
Thread title changed..
Reply
Save
Like
Mark Techer
Yeah that was an interesting read.

Conclusions

In the meantime, you can either buy speakers that fit the crossover in your processor, or in the case of separates, you can add a 2nd order filter between processor and amplifier to give a full-range speaker the roll-off needed to fall in line with the standard THX crossover.
Click to expand...
Or you do as I have done and custom build speakers to suit.
Reply
Save
Like
A
Are huge cineplex front speakers also crossed at 80Hz?
Reply
Save
Like
Mark Techer
atledreier said:
Are huge cineplex front speakers also crossed at 80Hz?
Click to expand...
In a THX certified cinema (or THX certified dubbing stage) yes. In a non certified cinema, usually not. The whole reason Tom Holman introduced the crossover in the Lucasfilm dubbing stages (now Skywalker Sound) when they were creating the standards was so the mixers could actually hear all of the low bass. The horn loaded speakers of a cinema in a baffle wall tend to roll off about 40Hz. So the question raised was then: How important is that first octave? The answer is very important. They discovered they could hear the low bass on a home HI FI system and not in the dubbing stage which film sound was mixed. Hence Bass management was born.

The system in this photo is impressive at 11.4 which I got to hear last night. It is fully bass managed even though the main speakers are as large as they are.

Attachments

See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
A
And by mass managed you mean 80Hz HPF?
Reply
Save
Like
Mark Techer
atledreier said:
And by mass managed you mean 80Hz HPF?
Click to expand...
I do believe he does use 80Hz and heavily equalizes the bass to be flat - something MCACC can't do. It is interesting that once you take out the 50~60 "boom" in a room, how much deep bass a sound track has. of course, at first, it seems that the 'slam' is missing because he has Eq'ed that out. Flat to 14 using REW apparently. It is physical. It has made his in chair 'shakers' redundant. I had actually assumed they were still connected but he told me after the first demo that they were no longer in service.
Reply
Save
Like
W
The amount of space available to you will determine the type of speakers you can set up within it. If you live in a tiny apartment, you’re not going to buy monstrous speakers that will take up the entire space. You’ll likely go with a much more conservatively sized set. Just remember that they won’t provide the same amount of power as a larger set of speakers would. Larger speakers will usually provide a better experience overall, but make sure you have the room for them.
Reply
Save
Like
21 - 37 of 37 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Home Theater Forum and Systems
A forum community dedicated to home theater owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, home theaters, troubleshooting, projects, DIY’s, product reviews and more!
Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums
REW Forum DIY Subwoofers - General Discussion New Member Introductions Home Audio Speakers Home Theater Design and Construction
Top