[lcaillo]

Mastering DVDs can be very complex. There are often slight differences in color. I am not sure why you assume that this is not in the film, however. You may want to post the name of the movie that you are using as an example and explain what improvements that you think have been made.

 

[lcaillo]

I was never aware of a "green smearing" problem with DVD as opposed to film. I have no idea what might be going on that you are experiencing.

 

[lcaillo]

I am sorry, but there are too many unknowns and variables in your comparisons and complaints to conclude much of anything. YouTube videos are hardly a way to make comparisons. I don't know what player or capture devices you are using, much less what kind of decoding problems they may have, nor what might be happening in the compression and encoding for youtube.

If you want to discuss the possible reasons for your problem, let's start with a particular comparison between discs and what equipment you are using, what signal types you are using, and what you are using to display them. What you have provided is essentially a rant and some defense of what you seem to think is an argument, and is not very informative. I am happy to try to figure out what you might be experiencing and why, but you will have to provide more information.

 

[lcaillo]

It is hard to comment on your posts. I can't realy follow your points. Your sentence construction is confusing, and the problems that you attribute to DVD are not familiar to me nor to others here.

TV broadcasts look better than what?

 

[lcaillo]

Why do you assume this is a problem with your discs and not your display. I can't really tell much from screen shots anyway, as there are too many variables to know where anything you see originates.

I have not seen what you describe, though I am not in your region, but I have also not heard of it from others.

 

[lcaillo]

I have really tried to figure out what you are talking about, but your poor grammar and contruction, combined with your reliance on screen shots make it very hard to figure out what your problem might be. Your insistence that DVDs have this as an inherent problem is hard to give much credibility to, since no one else seems to be experiencing the problem.

I will not bother to respond to these posts if you don't clean up your grammar and spelling to make them understandable. Please read the posting guidelines for the forum. There are reasons why we require proper grammar and spelling. It facilitates communication and avoids time wasting trying to sort out what someone is trying to say.

Screenshots are largely meaningless to communicate what is going on with a disc. There are too many variables involved to determine much about the color of the original source.

Your post seems to imply that I am involved in some conspiracy to conceal this problem. I assure you that I am not trying to "talk my way out" of anything. I am not color blind, and am actually a technician and calibrator with many years of experience with hundreds of systems, using many different sources. I have actually compared the outputs from test generators to the output of DVD, Laserdisc, BluRay, and other systems and have never identified a problem in the whites that you are describing.

There is obviously something different about your player or display, and I would happily try to sort it out with you if you can contruct meaningful sentences using proper grammar and spelling. You will have to discuss the problem in terms of finding a solution and not making acussations. You will also have to cease making insulting comments. These are all requirements that are clear in the forum rules. You have been given a great deal of flexibility, on the matter of language, but I am done. Follow the rules, post with clarity, post with respect for others, and post some facts that make sense. If you have evidence of others that have this problem, please link to it.

 

[lcaillo]

What display are you using? What have you done that rules out the display as the source of the problem? What players have you used? What kinds of connections? There are many possibilities.

 

[lcaillo]

Do all of the DVD sources demonstrate the problem on both displays?